Raising the minimum wage is often seen as a risky move. Critics warn that higher wages lead to fewer jobs, especially for young people and those in rural areas. But what if that’s not always the case? According to U.S. economist Casey Mulligan in his 2024 paper (Equilibrium Responses to Price Controls: A Supply-Chain Approach), labor markets react in more complex ways. Sometimes, higher wages can even create more employment opportunities — just in different forms.
This article explores how that works, how non-wage competition plays a role, and how Kazakhstan can apply this insight to build smarter wage policies.
Classic economic theory suggests that setting a wage floor above market level reduces demand for labor. But Mulligan offers a different lens: when wages are fixed, employers and workers start competing on other terms — work location, schedules, duties, and working conditions.
Instead of cutting wages, companies reduce job perks: workplaces move farther from home, shift hours become less flexible, and job roles get less attractive. Workers still compete for jobs, but now through their willingness to accept inconvenience, not lower pay.
Imagine someone previously took a lower-paying job close to home. Now, with a fixed wage, that same job might be across town. Or a company that used to train new hires now only accepts experienced workers — saving on training, but narrowing the talent pool.
This reshapes employment. It doesn’t necessarily reduce job numbers, but it changes who gets hired and on what terms.
In Kazakhstan, the minimum wage is a central part of social policy. Each time it’s raised, debates follow: Will it help low-income families? Will it push more people into informal work?
Mulligan’s model suggests:
• Employers don’t just cut jobs — they restructure how and whom they hire.
• Wage hikes can boost jobs in sectors where workers are flexible on location or shifts.
• The government can ease the adjustment by investing in worker mobility and training.
Four Policy Ideas for Smarter Wage Reforms
1. Measure job quality, not just quantity. Who gains from wage hikes? Who gets pushed out?
2. Support flexible work arrangements. If not all businesses can afford wage hikes, let them offer other benefits.
3. Invest in training and reskilling. This lowers hiring costs and expands job access.
4. Improve transport and digital infrastructure. Easier commuting makes wider job markets accessible.
As Mulligan shows, wages are only part of the employment equation. When wages are fixed, employers and workers negotiate on other terms. And those terms matter — especially for disadvantaged groups.
For Kazakhstan, this means raising the minimum wage doesn’t have to shrink the labor market. It can be an opportunity to rebalance it — if policies are designed wisely.