Higher incomes expand people’s choices. Yet our sense of financial wellbeing also depends on whom we compare ourselves with. Why does an improvement in material circumstances not always bring the satisfaction we expected?
Imagine someone whose earnings have increased. Everyday bills are easier to cover. Saving becomes possible. A holiday can be planned with greater confidence. Their material circumstances have improved.
But their social circle has changed too. Friends are buying larger homes, choosing more expensive holidays and discussing purchases that remain beyond this person’s budget. Their own progress begins to look less impressive.
This is a hypothetical example. It illustrates a distinction: financial resources and our assessment of our position among others can change at different speeds.
Income exists within a social environment
A working paper by Junwei Fan, Santiago Montoya-Blandon and Eugenio Proto, published in the IZA series in August 2026, examines social comparison among young adults. Using more than two million communication records from the NetHealth Study, the researchers reconstruct connections between university students. Economic circumstances are measured through family income, rather than the students’ own earnings.
The findings change depending on how the social network is treated. When connections are taken as given, wealthier contacts are associated with better mental-health measures. Once the model accounts for people choosing their contacts, the relationship reverses: higher peer income corresponds to more pronounced depressive symptoms.
People maintain some relationships, allow others to weaken and form new ones. The characteristics of their surroundings therefore cannot be fully separated from the process through which those surroundings develop.
The question is not simply how affluent our acquaintances are. It is also why those particular people have become our reference group.
Why the benchmark keeps moving
Income has several practical dimensions.
One is the quantity of goods and services a person can afford. Another is the resilience of their household budget. A third is how their resources compare with those of the people they regularly encounter.
These assessments need not move together.
Consider a family that can now save every month. This is a genuine improvement in financial resilience: an unexpected bill becomes easier to manage.
But if the family increasingly compares itself with acquaintances who own several properties, its savings may begin to feel inadequate.
The benchmark for having enough can move. A previously significant achievement becomes familiar, while expectations of a normal standard of living change.
This does not diminish the value of higher income. Being able to pay for healthcare, education, housing and unexpected expenses matters in its own right. Satisfaction with one’s position, however, does not have to increase in proportion to earnings.

Financial opportunities can expand at the same time as the standard people regard as sufficient rises.
Inequality becomes an everyday experience
In the study, income gaps are associated with worse mental-health measures in both directions: when peers are richer and when they are poorer. The authors interpret this as consistent with aversion to economic distance. These findings concern a particular sample and model.
For economic analysis, this provides a reason to look more closely at the environment in which people assess their opportunities.
National statistics describe the income distribution of millions. Everyday comparisons involve specific people: colleagues, former classmates, relatives and friends.
Visible differences can enter ordinary decisions. Can someone afford a shared trip? Can they sustain the level of spending their group considers normal? Do they repeatedly have to decline invitations?
These examples explain a possible mechanism. They are not separate findings established by the study.
The same income can provide comparable purchasing opportunities while being perceived differently in different social settings.
Our social surroundings change too
A social circle is not fixed.
A new job, a move or further education can introduce new acquaintances. Those relationships may expose people to different spending habits and expectations.
Suppose an employee receives a promotion and a higher salary. They also begin spending more time with colleagues for whom expensive holidays and larger homes are ordinary features of life.
Material progress has occurred. The background against which that progress is judged has changed as well.
This is a hypothetical example, not a scenario established by the research. It illustrates why two questions can produce different answers: “Am I living better than before?” and “How am I doing compared with those around me?”
The first uses personal history as its benchmark. The second uses other people’s circumstances.

What the study does not establish
The paper does not provide grounds for advising people to choose friends by income or reduce social contact to improve their wellbeing.
Modelled changes in communication are not equivalent to the results of a real-world programme. Their implications depend on the assumptions used in the calculations. Measures of depressive symptoms should not automatically be interpreted as clinical diagnoses.
A student sample does not represent the whole population. Applying its estimates directly to people in Kazakhstan would require additional research.
Nor does the paper establish that rising population incomes make people worse off. Changes in a person’s own resources, the incomes of their peers and the structure of their relationships are distinct processes.
What this adds to Kazakhstan’s income debate
An assessment of wellbeing should first establish what has changed materially.
Has income increased after inflation? Are essential expenses easier to meet? Has the household built a financial buffer? How reliable is its principal source of earnings?
These questions help determine whether a family’s real opportunities have expanded.
A separate question concerns how people interpret those changes. Expectations, personal goals and reference groups may matter. This is a direction for research, rather than a ready-made explanation of public sentiment.
Dissatisfaction cannot simply be attributed to comparisons with affluent acquaintances. It may reflect measurable pressures, including expensive rent, debt repayments or insecure employment.
Equally, an increase in average income does not capture people’s entire experience.
Studying this dimension of wellbeing in Kazakhstan would require local evidence that combines purchasing power, essential expenses and employment security with people’s assessments of their circumstances.
Material progress and the feeling of having enough
Understanding wellbeing requires attention to household resources and to how people evaluate their position.
The first helps measure material progress. The second helps explain why that progress may feel different from one person to another.
A family can earn more, build savings and still believe it is falling behind its familiar social circle. These assessments describe different aspects of its circumstances.
“How much do you earn?” remains an important question. Alongside it sits another: whom do you compare yourself with?
Elvira Baturova, EconomyKZ Research expert, exclusively for EconomyKZ.org


