EC[ON]OMY

Why some cities decline while others reinvent themselves

The closure of a major employer does not have to determine a city’s future. But a new economy rarely emerges from a single investor or industrial park. It requires businesses, skills, infrastructure and local institutions to develop together.

Urban decline does not always begin with poverty. Sometimes it begins with success that people have come to regard as permanent.

A large factory provides employment, orders for suppliers and income for local businesses. Educational programmes, professional traditions and residents’ expectations take shape around it. While the company is growing, this specialisation looks like an advantage.

But technologies, markets and demand change. A source of stability can then become a source of dependence.

The OECD’s Unpacking place transformation, published on 11 September 2026, examines why some places adapt while others remain trapped after economic disruption. Its focus extends beyond investment and infrastructure to local leadership, trust, place identity and the capacity to act collectively. www.oecd.org

The central question is how a city uses its accumulated capabilities when its previous economic model stops delivering development.

Similar shocks, different outcomes

A related OECD study examines industrial restructuring in functional urban areas across Finland, France, Spain, Sweden, the United Kingdom and the United States.

Among the urban areas exposed to moderate or severe restructuring pressure since the 2000s:

  • 19% maintained a resilient employment trajectory.
  • 34% recovered after an initial decline within a decade.
  • 47% did not recover their employment losses over the period examined.

These figures classify employment trajectories within the study sample. They are not probabilities that any given city will “die”. Recovering job numbers did not necessarily mean a balanced recovery: in roughly three-quarters of the episodes analysed, at least one indicator deteriorated over the following decade – employment, the employment-to-population ratio or productivity. www.oecd.org

Why do outcomes differ?

The loss of a major employer rarely stops at the factory gate. Suppliers lose orders, household incomes fall, and demand for shops and services weakens. Local public finances come under pressure. Some residents leave.

One city can redirect people, knowledge and capital towards new activities. Another has few alternatives available.

Resilience depends on the strength of the principal employer and on the opportunities that exist beyond it.

Economic renewal does not mean abandoning industry

Successful urban transformations are often reduced to simple stories: an industrial city builds a museum, university or technology park and acquires a new economy.

Behind these symbols is usually much more demanding work.

In the Basque Country, renewal combined the modernisation of traditional industries with knowledge-intensive services, cluster policies and investment in human capital. The Guggenheim Museum became a prominent symbol of Bilbao’s transformation, but it was not its sole driver.

Pittsburgh, historically associated with steel, broadened its economic base through education, healthcare and technology. Universities, medical institutions and public-private collaboration played important roles.

These examples do not establish a universal prescription to replace factories with services.

A city needs to identify which capabilities can be preserved and upgraded, which relationships can support new activities and where external assistance is necessary.

Money can be directed to a region. Sustained collaboration between businesses, educational institutions and local government has to be built there.

Four paths to a new economy

The source review identifies several routes to transformation.

The first is upgrading an existing specialisation. Italy’s Riviera del Brenta industrial district developed its footwear industry by moving into higher-value market segments. Existing skills became a foundation for renewal.

The second is developing a new specialisation. In Linköping, Sweden, technology businesses developed through cooperation between the university and companies, including firms emerging from the research environment.

The third is attracting capabilities from outside. Cork, Ireland, used foreign investment to develop pharmaceutical and technology activities.

The fourth is diversifying by combining existing knowledge. Eindhoven built a broader high-technology system on accumulated industrial and engineering capabilities.

These approaches can complement one another. A place can modernise established businesses, develop suppliers and attract new production at the same time.

The choice should reflect actual capabilities: workers, firms, research institutions, infrastructure and access to markets.

An industrial city adapting its built environment to new economic activities

Why places become stuck

A shortage of resources is not the only obstacle to renewal. Sometimes the established system itself becomes a barrier.

Three forms of lock-in are particularly relevant.

Functional lock-in: relationships between businesses and suppliers become too closed, making it harder for new participants and ideas to emerge.

Cognitive lock-in: a prolonged structural shift is mistaken for a temporary downturn. Local actors wait for previous demand to return rather than prepare for a different model.

Political lock-in: decisions concentrate on preserving the existing structure even as its viability weakens.

The Ruhr region’s experience illustrates the distinction between cushioning industrial decline and creating new sources of development. Support for coal and social measures helped manage the transition. They could not substitute for diversification, education and new capabilities.

This distinction matters.

Workers and businesses need assistance during difficult periods. That assistance should also connect to the territory’s future.

Protecting incomes today and building tomorrow’s economic base are two tasks that need to be pursued together.

Retraining works when new skills are needed

Retraining is one of the most common responses to structural decline.

But training does not create jobs by itself.

If local businesses do not need the new skills, an educational programme may make it easier for a worker to move elsewhere. That can benefit the individual without resolving the local economy’s problem.

The reverse can also happen: an investor is ready to establish production but cannot find workers, housing or essential services.

Local development therefore requires coordination:

  • Education programmes should reflect employers’ needs.
  • Investment projects should account for workforce preparation.
  • Transport and housing should support practical access to jobs.
  • Enterprise support should help generate demand for skilled labour.

These elements complement one another. Having more of one does not necessarily compensate for the absence of another.

Why trust matters economically

The OECD highlights the “soft infrastructure” of transformation: local leadership, social connections, identity and the ability to reach agreement.

These do not replace roads, electricity or finance. They influence whether people and institutions can work together effectively.

Residents may see a new strategy as a rejection of their city’s history. Businesses may doubt whether policies will remain stable. Educational institutions may train workers without sufficient engagement with employers.

Even well-founded projects can then encounter resistance and poor coordination.

Leadership in this setting is a shared responsibility involving government, businesses, universities, development organisations and residents.

At the same time, trust and leadership should not automatically be credited with every difference between successful and unsuccessful places. Their contribution requires investigation. Individual case studies do not provide a universal causal formula.

The practical conclusion is more straightforward: participants need a clear purpose, dependable rules and an opportunity to influence decisions that change their lives.

An industrial city adapting its built environment to new economic activities

Quick results should reinforce a long-term strategy

Transformation can take a decade or longer. Political and budget cycles are much shorter.

This creates a risk of repeated restarts: a new programme, new funding conditions and new performance measures. Before participants have built working relationships, the rules change.

That does not mean early results can be postponed indefinitely.

After mass redundancies, people need prompt employment assistance, accessible training and social support. Visible improvements to the urban environment can also help maintain confidence.

Short-term measures should nevertheless form part of a longer strategy.

Attracting sophisticated manufacturing requires advance coordination of electricity supply, logistics, skills and housing. Policymakers also need to consider whether a new project could draw workers away from other essential activities.

Funding should follow a workable sequence of actions. The amount allocated is not a substitute for assessing the quality of decisions and outcomes.

A city’s economy extends beyond its boundaries

People often live in one municipality and work in another. Suppliers serve businesses in neighbouring areas. Universities and research centres collaborate with firms beyond their own city.

The geographical scale of policy should therefore match the problem.

Social support may require neighbourhood-level action. Transport and employment policy may need coordination across an entire commuting area. Innovation policy can depend on interregional connections.

If an economic strategy stops at the administrative boundary, some of its most important relationships remain outside its reach.

A city needs connections with its surrounding territory as well as a plan for development within its limits.

The next shocks will also affect cities without ageing factories

Vulnerability was once associated primarily with heavy industry and extraction. Today, digital technologies, population ageing and the low-carbon transition are also reshaping local employment.

OECD estimates published in 2024 suggested that around 26% of workers across member countries were exposed to generative AI. The estimate was 32% in urban areas and 21% in non-urban areas. Exposure concerns tasks that technology could change or accelerate. It does not mean that the same proportion of workers will lose their jobs. www.oecd.org

Technologically advanced urban economies therefore need to adapt too.

The low-carbon transition presents different challenges, changing technologies, demand for qualifications and the prospects of energy-intensive production.

Where public policy accelerates structural change, preparation for workers and places should begin early.

Assistance after redundancies remains necessary. Anticipatory action can broaden the available transition routes before choices become constrained.

What this means for Kazakhstan

International experience provides grounds to reconsider how Kazakhstan develops cities with pronounced sectoral specialisations.

Foreign percentages cannot be transferred to Kazakhstani cities as ready-made forecasts. Each territory needs its own diagnosis.

In my view, that diagnosis should answer five questions.

First, how dependent is the city on one employer? The assessment should include its employees, suppliers, associated services and household incomes linked to its orders.

Second, which capabilities can be used in other activities? Engineering, repair, metalworking, logistics and maintenance can support diversification where corresponding demand exists.

Third, can local businesses grow independently? A supplier serving a single customer shares that customer’s risks. Reaching other buyers can strengthen the wider system.

Fourth, are investment plans aligned with skills and infrastructure? An industrial site without workers, reliable energy and transport access does not constitute a functioning economic ecosystem.

Fifth, can existing residents access the new opportunities? Higher output or average wages are insufficient if new jobs remain inaccessible to displaced workers and living costs rise faster than their incomes.

Results should be assessed through productivity, sustained employment, incomes and quality of life together.

The central lesson: cities need the capacity to renew themselves

A city does not necessarily begin to decline on the day a factory closes. Its vulnerability develops earlier, when economic life becomes tied to a single scenario.

Finding another major employer does not automatically remove that vulnerability. Without other businesses, skills and institutions, one dependency can simply replace another.

A resilient city uses accumulated knowledge, develops new activities and helps residents move between them.

Investment and infrastructure are necessary. So are coordinated action, trust and a long-term approach to decisions.

Strong cities preserve what remains useful from their history and create opportunities to carry it forward under new economic conditions.

Aruzhan Tolegenkyzy, EconomyKZ Research expert, exclusively for EconomyKZ.org

Scroll to Top