EC[ON]OMY

How can KZT 6.5 trillion in investment deliver real results?

Following the President’s address and the announcement of the large-scale “People’s Construction” programme, which envisages allocating approximately KZT 6.5 trillion from the National Fund by the end of 2029, many Kazakhstanis have asked: will this money genuinely serve its purpose? Could it disappear into questionable projects, inflated estimates, opaque procurement and corruption schemes? Such concerns are understandable after years of failures in public projects and beyond.

But I suggest looking at the problem more broadly. Corruption flourishes where opportunities exist, conditions are favourable and the system allows it. No system can eliminate theft or abuse entirely. Yet work can be organised so that stealing becomes substantially harder, concealing violations becomes almost impossible, and responsibility for participants’ decisions and actions is clear.

Stronger inspections and oversight expose troubling facts, but do not necessarily prevent them. Meanwhile, demands for reports increase officials’ workloads and encourage them to focus on presenting a favourable picture. This points to the need to change the system for preparing, organising and managing investment projects.

What should we focus on?

KZT 6.5 Trillion in Investment: How to Deliver Results
Five conditions for effective investment: project selection, project team, preparation, digitalisation and contracts

1. Oversight must begin before funding is allocated

Even before detailed design and cost documentation is prepared, clear project selection criteria are needed: demonstrated demand, economic justification, CAPEX and OPEX calculations, feasibility, resource availability and risk assessment.

Once a project has been selected and approved, a system of predefined indicators and milestones should be established. These should measure progress towards the intended result, rather than budget expenditure alone.

This involves checking intermediate results at milestones and comparing them with the plan. In project management, earned value management provides a way to connect progress, expenditure and schedule performance, and to forecast completion.

It helps identify the causes of delays and cost overruns, allowing specific action to eliminate or mitigate emerging risks.

There is another important point. Every project should have a contingency reserve to cover risks. If the team manages those risks successfully and leaves part of the reserve unused, why not consider a mechanism to reward the savings achieved?

Would that not encourage sound decisions and thoughtful management, rather than public reprimands and a search for someone to blame?

KZT 6.5 Trillion in Investment: How to Deliver Results

2. Public investment projects cannot be managed effectively through sectoral ministries alone

A modern investment project almost always spans several sectors. Construction, equipment, technology, logistics and financing involve different capabilities and different agencies.

If each agency or ministry is responsible only for its own part, who is responsible for the final outcome?

We need a matrix management model and fully functioning project offices operating at national scale. Project activities should be separated from ministries’ routine operational work.

Project offices now exist in almost every agency. Yet they are embedded in day-to-day operations, where objectives conflict and sometimes directly contradict one another. As a result, a project office becomes another reporting department.

3. Project management must start with the idea, not the construction phase

First, we need to understand what we intend to create, why it is needed, how it will be financed, and which technologies and resources will be used. A feasibility study must be prepared, risks assessed, participants identified and working arrangements agreed.

The original assessment puts the cost of insufficient foresight during preparation of the Almaty CHP-2 project at 256%.* The example illustrates how expensive changes to a technical concept and inadequate preparation of initial decisions can become.

A project may remain unfinished for years despite substantial financing. The source article also cites a seven-year delay against the original schedule for Astana CHP-3.*

For the state, this means more than additional expenditure. It means capital tied up, economic benefits forgone and an infrastructure problem left unresolved. Such examples undermine public confidence in government initiatives.

Meanwhile, estimates place project management costs at between 2% and 15% of a project’s budget. During budgeting, these amounts are often treated as additional expenditure that makes the project more expensive.

Yet they are rarely recalled when implementation problems force a decision to increase the budget.

4. Construction needs to go digital – in practice

Construction is among the sectors lagging in digitalisation. At least three tasks need attention.

First, put the underlying data in order.

We still lack a unified digital database bringing together territorial information: land plots, utility networks, master plans, detailed development plans and other relevant data.

Such a resource would help establish, before a project begins, whether a site is suitable for construction, what infrastructure it needs and whether existing networks have sufficient capacity.

Second, move from 2D to BIM.

Kazakhstan already has a regulatory framework requiring the use of Building Information Modelling. From 2026, the requirement is being introduced in stages for selected categories of facilities, with much broader coverage envisaged from 2030.

In practice, however, much design work still follows the traditional approach of two-dimensional drawings. The main argument against moving to BIM is the cost of software.

Why should the state not negotiate preferential licences for design organisations with leading developers?

BIM is more than an attractive three-dimensional image. It is a digital model linking design decisions, quantities of work, schedules and costs. It can help identify errors and clashes before construction begins, improve planning and compare actual progress with the plan.

Third, bring in artificial intelligence.

Collect and analyse data, track deviations, forecast risks and flag problems before they lead to missed deadlines and higher project costs.

Perhaps then we will stop learning about construction problems only through reports announcing another deadline extension and another increase in the estimate.

But there is a qualification: persuading the construction industry to digitalise is no longer enough. It is time to require it. That calls for managerial resolve and clear, binding rules.

5. Move from formal agreements to professional contracts

Kazakhstan’s prevailing practice of turnkey construction contracts, often given the impressive label of EPC contracts, creates uncertainty from the outset.

Schedules, scope and costs are defined broadly, with references to estimates and work programmes that are often not ready when the contract is signed. During implementation, these can be revised and formalised through supplementary agreements, even while procedural requirements are observed.

The initially approved budget then grows rapidly, supported by formally reasoned explanations.

FIDIC contract forms are used in construction in developed countries. They allow participants’ roles, authority, responsibilities, decision-making procedures and change management arrangements to be defined in advance.

A contract should be more than a document with a cost estimate attached. It should establish the rules for managing the entire delivery process.

The source article cites projects in the UAE as examples of combining PMBOK-based project management with FIDIC contract forms.* It is the combination of competent management and professional contracts that creates a manageable delivery process, rather than merely documenting the relationship between client and contractor.

Public investment requires professional management

For me, these proposals share one principle:

Public investment is more than money that must be allocated and monitored properly. It consists of projects that require professional management.

Inspections can be intensified, commissions established and more reports demanded. But if a project lacks sound justification, demand has not been demonstrated, participants are not coordinated and responsibility is unclear, strict subsequent oversight cannot ensure success.

We need more than another system for reporting how funds have been spent. We need a system capable of bringing investment projects to their planned results.

Svetlana Nurtazina, civil engineer, PhD, certified project manager, specifically for www.economyKZ.org

Scroll to Top