Kazakhstan’s Commissioner for the Protection of Entrepreneurs’ Rights, Kanat Nurov, has submitted proposals to the Prime Minister aimed at making the automated risk management system (RMS) fully operational and reducing the administrative burden on businesses.
The proposals support the President’s policy of improving the state control and supervision system. A key instrument in this transition is the RMS envisaged under the “regulation from a clean slate” reform.
How the automated risk management system should work
In 2021, Kazakhstan adopted legislation introducing a new regulatory policy for entrepreneurial activity. The reform rests on the principle that government regulation is justified only where risks exist to human life and health, the environment, public order or public morals.
The reform envisaged a flexible automated RMS that would use information system data to classify businesses by risk level, identify entities for inspection and generate inspection schedules. Where such a system is absent, legislation limits inspections and preventive controls involving site visits to no more than 5% of business entities.
However, more than four years later, one of the reform’s central mechanisms is still not fully operational.
According to Ministry of National Economy figures cited in the proposals, automated solutions have been introduced in only 15 of the 66 regulatory areas scheduled for automation in 2026. They remain absent in the other 51 areas. Reliable data on the number of businesses subject to oversight are also unavailable, preventing an objective assessment of compliance with the 5% limit.
Statistics from the Prosecutor General’s Office also point to a need to review existing approaches. In 2025, 92% of business inspections were unscheduled, while the share of inspections that found no violations rose from 37% to 43%. More than 1,500 unlawful inspections were also identified.
How inspection burdens differ by business size
A substantial imbalance also exists in the distribution of inspections across business categories. In 2025, small businesses faced one inspection for every 64 entities. By comparison, medium-sized businesses faced an average of 2.5 inspections per entity, while large businesses faced 4.8.
The Ombudsman’s submission presents this difference as a more than 150-fold increase in inspection intensity between the small and medium-sized business categories, arguing that it creates additional barriers to business growth.
The imbalance also extends to administrative penalties. Of KZT 96.4 billion in fines, KZT 60.3 billion, or 63%, fell on large businesses.
Under 302 articles of the Code of Administrative Offences, fines are predominantly expressed in monthly calculation indices (MCI), a statutory unit used to calculate fines and certain other payments. Fine amounts increase two to four times depending on the business category, although companies’ revenues can differ by tens or hundreds of times.
Percentage-based fines are provided for in only 23 articles. Their rates also vary by business category, meaning that business size is taken into account twice.
Why automation alone is not enough
As Kanat Nurov emphasised:
“This is not about shifting inspections from large businesses to small and medium-sized enterprises – a balance is needed. Only a transition from mass on-site inspections to data-driven digital oversight, supported by a fully functioning automated risk management system, can provide that balance.”
According to the Business Ombudsman, the problem lies not only in insufficient automation but also in the absence of a unified, scientifically grounded methodology for assessing risks. Without such a methodology, digitalisation alone cannot ensure objective government oversight.
Three proposals submitted to the Prime Minister
The Business Ombudsman’s Office has proposed the following measures:
- Develop a unified methodology for the automated RMS. It should define risk assessment principles, data sources, procedures for creating risk profiles, data quality requirements and mechanisms for selecting entities for oversight.
- Introduce a unified digital RMS in phases, starting with regulatory areas where businesses face the highest levels of administrative pressure.
- Ensure transparency of RMS criteria by publishing the criteria and the weighting coefficients used in risk models.
The Office argues that implementing these measures would enable a transition to government oversight based on objective risk assessment.

Source: Letter published on the website of Kazakhstan’s Business Ombudsman, in Russian.


