EC[ON]OMY

Labor, suppliers, and startup success: unraveling city dynamics

Why do some cities generate waves of new companies while others remain stuck in stagnation? The answer lies in the ecosystem. The presence of suppliers, the structure of the labor market, and cross-industry links determine where small firms and startups are most likely to emerge. Research shows that labor and supplier networks are the key factors, while consumer demand and venture capital play a smaller role.

Entrepreneurial activity in cities depends heavily on the local ecosystem. Access to capital alone doesn’t guarantee a surge in new firms. What matters more is how supply chains are organized, who is available in the labor market, and how industries interact with one another.

The strongest factor is labor. New businesses appear where the right workers are available. People are not only potential employees but also future entrepreneurs themselves. The diversity of skills in a city directly correlates with the number of new firms. In fact, the workforce matters more than customers or even suppliers.

But suppliers still play an important role. When a city has many small companies that can quickly support new projects, the barriers to entry for startups are much lower. This is the essence of the Chinitz hypothesis. Cities with a network of independent suppliers tend to have smaller firms on average, which means more entrepreneurs per worker. Where large corporations dominate supply chains, small businesses struggle to survive.

Consumer demand has surprisingly little impact. Retail trade expands faster in big cities, but overall, the size of the customer base doesn’t strongly affect self-employment. Even in healthcare or services for the elderly, a larger client pool doesn’t necessarily translate into more entrepreneurs.

Venture capital is not the universal solution either. It matters for certain industries, especially in high-tech manufacturing. But at the city level, its presence has little connection to the overall self-employment rate. Funding tends to concentrate in narrow sectors and doesn’t shape broad entrepreneurial ecosystems.

Cross-industry connections, on the other hand, are crucial. When different sectors share workers and ideas, new companies emerge more quickly. Labor mobility – the ability of workers to move easily between industries – drives the creation of new plants and offices. These “invisible bridges” between industries strengthen the entrepreneurial climate of a city.

The number of small firms today is directly linked to future job growth. Cities that had more small businesses in the 1970s and 1980s later saw faster growth in both population and incomes. A large base of small players makes the economy more flexible and resilient.

The conclusion is clear: a city’s institutional ecosystem shapes entrepreneurship as much as demographics do. The workforce is the main driver. Suppliers lower the barriers for new businesses. Cross-industry ties fuel fresh ideas. Consumer demand and venture capital remain secondary. For cities that want to grow, the key is to develop people and build networks of independent market participants. Only in such an environment can new firms truly take root and thrive.

Alen Serik, expert of the  portal EconomyKZ.org

Scroll to Top