EC[ON]OMY

How city demographics influence self-employment rates

Why do some cities turn into hubs of small business, while others remain dominated by big corporations? The answer lies in people – their age, education, and the jobs they hold. Research shows that these factors explain about half of the differences in self-employment rates across U.S. cities. Where older and better-educated workers are concentrated, entrepreneurship tends to flourish.

Entrepreneurship in cities doesn’t start with capital or tax breaks. It starts with people. Men are more likely to open their own businesses than women. The likelihood of becoming self-employed rises with age. By the time workers reach their sixties, they are nearly twice as likely to run their own business compared to younger peers. Experience, savings, and the desire to control one’s time all play a role.

Education adds another layer. College graduates are much more likely to start a business than those without a diploma. High school dropouts rarely go down the entrepreneurial path. Higher education doesn’t guarantee success, but it provides the skills, networks, and confidence needed to take the leap.

Industry matters too. Construction is one of the most entrepreneurial sectors – self-employment here reaches around 10%. Independent contractors dominate homebuilding and related trades. Information services also stand out. Lawyers, consultants, and accountants often operate independently. Low barriers to entry make it easier to work for yourself.

The picture is very different in high-tech manufacturing. Despite the fame of tech founders, fewer than 1% of workers in these industries are self-employed. The capital requirements are too high. Large-scale production is the norm, and the number of entrepreneurs is small relative to the overall workforce.

Healthcare and education also show low levels of entrepreneurship. Large institutions and nonprofit organizations dominate, leaving little room for independent players. Even highly skilled doctors and teachers rarely become self-employed.

Differences between cities are striking. In West Palm Beach, Florida, one in ten residents is self-employed. In Dayton, Ohio, it’s just one in thirty. Honolulu also ranks among the leaders in entrepreneurial activity. On the other end of the spectrum are several cities in the U.S. Northeast, where demographics and industrial structure hold back small business growth.

Florida is a telling example. A large share of older residents creates a favorable climate for entrepreneurship. They not only start businesses themselves but also create demand for services, fueling the local market. Population aging, often seen as a challenge, turns out to be a driver of self-employment.

Age and education explain about half of the variation in self-employment rates across metropolitan areas. This is the key finding. Human capital matters more than the “entrepreneurial spirit” of a city or even the availability of venture capital. Startup financing is important for certain industries but does little to shape overall self-employment.

The structure of employment in a city is equally important. Where construction and services dominate, entrepreneurship is stronger. Where heavy industry prevails, self-employment is lower. Consider San Jose – the heart of Silicon Valley. Despite its global reputation as an innovation hub, its self-employment rate is among the lowest in the country. Successful startups exist, but they hire workers rather than expand the number of self-employed individuals.

These insights highlight that entrepreneurship is not a universal phenomenon. It’s shaped by a mix of factors, with demographics and jobs at the core. Age, education, and industry explain a large share of differences. The rest depends on local conditions – supplier networks, labor diversity, cross-industry connections. But the foundation is always people.

The message for cities is clear. Aging populations, rising education levels, and shifts toward less capital-intensive industries directly affect entrepreneurial growth. Cities that want more small businesses must invest in human capital. Tax breaks and incubators can help, but they work only where skilled and motivated people already exist.

The bottom line: urban entrepreneurship begins with residents. The older and more educated the workforce, the higher the chances of strong small business growth. Demographics and employment structure aren’t side notes – they are the keys to understanding the economic future of cities.

Alen Serik, expert of the  portal EconomyKZ.org

Scroll to Top