Family structure significantly influences children’s educational achievements. PSID data allow for a detailed analysis of this impact. Children raised by biological mothers tend to show higher educational results. Meanwhile, children raised by stepmothers, adoptive mothers, and guardians face different realities. Let’s take a closer look at these differences.
PSID: The Basis for Analysis
PSID (Panel Study of Income Dynamics) is one of the most comprehensive studies tracking changes in American families since 1968. This study includes data on income, educational levels, and family structure. For our analysis, we selected children who were at least 23 years old by 1997. This helps to avoid potential errors related to incomplete education.
Educational Levels: What Do Years of Education Mean?
In the U.S., 12 years of education correspond to completing high school. This is equivalent to a high school diploma. Fourteen years of education indicate the first two years of college. Sixteen or more years suggest the completion of a full bachelor’s degree. PSID data show that the average level of education is 12.73 years. About 81.9% of children completed at least 12 years of schooling, which is a basic indicator of secondary education. Approximately 30.1% continued their education for 14 or more years, indicating post-secondary education. Only 14.1% completed 16 or more years of education, indicating higher education attainment.

Children grow up in different types of families. PSID data illustrate the types of mothers. Biological mothers raised 83.2% of children. This is the main group. Children raised by adoptive mothers make up 1.3%. The share of children raised by stepmothers is 2%. Guardians raised 0.7% of children. About 12.8% of children were under the care of mothers with an unclear status.
Educational achievements depend on the type of mother. Children raised by biological mothers receive, on average, 12.81 years of education. Stepmothers’ children have a lower average by 0.75 years. For children raised by adoptive mothers, the difference is 0.62 years. The greatest gap is seen among children under guardianship — their average education level is 1.33 years lower compared to children raised by biological mothers.
There are various factors that can explain these differences.
Evolutionary psychology indicates that biological mothers tend to invest more time and resources in their children. This is related to the instinctive need to protect their offspring. As a result, biological children receive more support, which affects their educational achievements. Children of stepmothers and adoptive mothers face different circumstances, where attention and resources are distributed differently.
PSID analysis highlights important points. Even in families where both biological and adoptive children are raised, biological children have an advantage. Their education level remains consistently higher. The average for biological children is 12.81 years. On the contrary, children of stepmothers and guardians face challenges. Their average achievement is lower.
A regression analysis was conducted to confirm the findings. Variables that affect results were considered, including the education level of parents, the child’s gender, and belonging to the PSID SEO sample. The analysis results confirmed the hypothesis. Children raised by adoptive mothers receive 0.998 fewer years of education compared to biological children. The difference for stepmothers’ children is 0.598 years. Children under guardianship lag by 1.27 years. These differences are statistically significant and indicate the impact of the type of mother on education levels.
Higher education is a separate topic. Completing 12 years of schooling does not guarantee success.
Entering college requires additional effort and support. Parental support is crucial. Children raised by biological mothers receive more assistance. This helps them enter and study in college. Children of stepmothers and guardians face challenges. Transitioning to college is more difficult for them. Parental support and attention play an essential role during this stage.
Family structure has a significant impact on educational achievements. Children raised by biological mothers often show higher results. Meanwhile, children raised by stepmothers, adoptive mothers, and guardians face certain challenges. Differences in levels of support and resources influence educational success. PSID data confirm this.


