EC[ON]OMY

Strategic Planning or Strategic Drift?

Strategic planning is the foundation of a country’s sustainable development. It ensures policy predictability, economic stability, and confidence for both businesses and citizens about the future.

However, in Kazakhstan strategic planning often doesn’t match real actions, leading to strategic drift—when long-term goals are replaced by short-term, reactive decisions. Last year, the National Plan 2029 was approved, along with more than 50 industry-specific strategies aimed at systematic development. Yet, this year, decisions are being made that contradict the original plan, raising concerns about how strategy is implemented.

What is strategic drift?

Strategic drift happens when official strategic documents lose connection with real policies. Instead of sticking to long-term goals, the government reacts to current challenges with short-term fixes, often without considering the bigger picture.

Where is the strategy if tax policies are unpredictable?

One of the five key principles of the National Plan 2029 is “Protecting and developing entrepreneurship through a clear, predictable, and investor-friendly economic policy.”

The Public Finance Management Concept 2030, adopted in 2023, states that “to increase tax revenues, improvements will be made to indirect taxes (VAT, excise duties) and corporate income tax, considering international best practices, including those of the EAEU countries.”

However, instead of a systematic tax reform, we see scattered, one-off tax initiatives:

• Raising VAT from 12% to 20% – without considering economic growth rates.

• Lowering the VAT registration threshold from 78 million to 15 million tenge – without assessing its impact on small businesses.

Such inconsistencies between strategic goals and actual policies lead to strategic drift, making businesses lose trust in government initiatives. In countries with stable tax systems, changes are introduced gradually and aligned with steady economic growth.

How can we stop strategic drift?

Government policies must be predictable. Any reform or support measure should have clear timelines, implementation conditions, and anticipated outcomes.

To achieve this, Kazakhstan should:

✅ Fix key tax policies for 5–10 years. Businesses need to know what tax rates and conditions to expect in the coming years so they can plan investments effectively. A stable framework prevents chaotic, short-term tax reforms that ignore economic realities.

✅ Set fixed timelines for tax incentives and subsidies. These should have clear expiration dates, and any extension or cancellation should be announced well in advance. For example, if VAT is set to increase, there should be a structured, phasedplan with predefined review periods.

✅ Tie tax changes to economic conditions. Any tax reform should align with macroeconomic indicators. For example, VAT should only be increased when GDP grows by at least 5% for several years, and the change should be implemented gradually to minimize the impact on businesses and consumers. Similarly, lowering the VAT registration threshold shouldn’t happen overnight—it should be phased in to give small businesses time to adjust.

Why does this matter?

Strategic drift weakens governance and erodes public and business trust. Kazakhstan needs a reform in strategic decision-making where policies are based on clear economic benchmarks, not on short-term adjustments.

The question is not whether Kazakhstan needs a strategic course—it already has one. The real question is: Will it actually be followed?

If strategic drift continues, the economy will remain in a state of chaotic management, making long-term development and economic stability harder to achieve. Strategic planning must not remain just a document—it needs to work in practice.

 

The National Bureau of Economic Research specifically for the portal www.economykz.org

Scroll to Top