EC[ON]OMY

Link between competition and inflation in Kazakhstan

High inflation rarely appears “on its own.” Behind rising prices there is almost always market structure – how easily companies can raise prices without losing customers. A new study by the National Bank of Kazakhstan shows that when markets are highly concentrated and competition is weak, inflation becomes more persistent and harder to control.

The paper is a working study by the Monetary Policy Department of the National Bank of Kazakhstan, prepared by Saule Duskaliyeva, Agiya Galimova, and Sarsen Zhanabekov. The authors examine whether there is a stable link between the level of competition and price dynamics in Kazakhstan, and how important this link is for inflation policy.

In advanced economies, competition has long been seen as an “anti-inflation tool.” When markets are open and entry is easy, firms are forced to keep prices in check. Kazakhstan’s economy works differently. A large state presence, dominance of a few major players, and limited market access create conditions where raising prices is often easier than improving efficiency.

The authors clearly state their main idea: the higher the level of imperfect competition, the stronger the inflation pressure. To test this, they use a quantitative approach, measuring markups as a proxy for market power.

Competition cannot be measured directly. That is why the study relies on indirect indicators. The key one is the markup – the gap between prices and marginal costs. The higher the markup, the more room firms have to increase prices.

At the aggregate level, markups are calculated as the ratio of GDP to labor compensation. At the sector level, the Roeger methodology is used to estimate the Lerner index, a classic measure of market power. The analysis also includes profit margins, returns on capital, economic openness, and key macro indicators.

The study covers the period from 1998 to 2020. This allows the authors to track long-term trends rather than short-term shocks.

Before turning to econometric results, the authors describe the competitive environment in Kazakhstan. The picture is tough.

In most core sectors, market concentration is high. In mining, the three largest companies account for more than half of total output. In transport and storage, their share is about one third. In some manufacturing industries, such as tobacco or car production, the top three firms control 80–100% of the market.

The concentration is even more striking when looking at the largest 10% of firms. Across the whole economy, they produce around 88% of total output. In the financial sector, this figure reaches 90–98%. This means pricing decisions are made by a narrow group of companies, while market discipline is weak.

The role of the quasi-state sector is also emphasized. In transport, industry, communications, and energy, the state still plays a large role. Privatization has only been partly implemented. This raises entry barriers and reduces price competition.

Prices in Kazakhstan are formally free, but in practice many of them are regulated. This applies to natural monopolies such as electricity, water, heating, and gas. Since 2015, long-term tariff systems have been in place, and since 2018 there have been measures to limit tariff growth.

In the short term, such policies can restrain inflation. The study shows that in some years, regulated tariffs made a very small or even negative contribution to the consumer price index. But this comes at a cost. Suppressed tariffs reduce investment capacity, increase infrastructure wear, and create delayed inflation pressure.

Another example is price caps. The authors show a “pull-up” effect: market prices quickly move toward the ceiling, wiping out price competition. Inflation may look lower on paper, but market signals become distorted.

Over the period studied, the average markup in Kazakhstan is close to 3. This means that, on average, prices are three times higher than marginal costs, while labor compensation accounts for about 30% of GDP. For comparison, similar studies by the European Central Bank put this figure at around 2 for EU countries.

Average profit margins reach 46%, and returns on capital exceed 300%. The authors note that these values partly reflect data limitations. Still, their scale points to strong market power.

Simple correlation analysis does not show a strong link between inflation and markups. But once regression models are applied, the picture changes. At the aggregate level, markups become a statistically significant driver of inflation. As market power rises, prices increase.

Money supply and the real effective exchange rate of the tenge also enter the model as significant factors, with time lags. This confirms that inflation in Kazakhstan is shaped by both monetary factors and market structure.

At the sector level, regression results are less stable. The authors explain this by limited and highly aggregated data. Estimating markups using the Roeger method requires detailed statistics, which are often not publicly available.

Still, visual analysis shows a pattern: sectors with higher markups tend to have higher average price levels. This applies to manufacturing, trade, and transport. The link is not perfect, but the trend is clear.

The study reaches a cautious but important conclusion. Yes, there is a link between competition and inflation in Kazakhstan. It is not always linear and not easy to measure. But high market concentration, a strong state role, and weak competition create persistent inflation pressure.

Administrative price controls may bring short-term relief. In the long run, however, they only delay price growth and reduce the effectiveness of monetary policy.

Stable price dynamics cannot be achieved by interest rates and money supply alone. Structural reforms are needed – stronger competition, lower entry barriers, more transparency, and less manual control over prices.

Lina Yegil kizi, expert of the EconomyKZ.org portal

Scroll to Top