EC[ON]OMY

Future pension trends: declining replacement rates

Pension systems in advanced economies are going through a quiet but deep transformation. There are no dramatic headlines and no street protests. Yet the consequences may be more serious than many loud reforms of the past. Governments no longer promise to maintain living standards after retirement. More and more often, they only guarantee a basic income. Everything else is left to the individual.

The OECD Pensions at a Glance 2025 report captures this shift in numbers. And those numbers are tougher than political statements. The main trend is simple and uncomfortable.

Future replacement rates are falling. On average across the OECD, a full-career worker on an average wage who retires in the future will receive about 63% of their previous net income. This is an average. In several countries the figure drops below 40%. Among them are Estonia, Ireland, Korea, and Lithuania. Even where replacement rates look higher, they are increasingly driven by redistribution and basic benefits, not by earnings-related pensions.

A few decades ago, such figures would have been seen as a sign of crisis. Today, the OECD describes them as the result of deliberate policy choices. Pension systems are adapting to demographics, labor markets, and fiscal limits. And this adaptation means lower pensions for future generations.

For a long time, the replacement rate was a simple benchmark. It showed how much of a worker’s previous income a pension could replace. In postwar welfare-state models, this share often exceeded 70–80%. For many people, a pension was effectively a continuation of their salary. That logic is fading. And the OECD report clearly explains why. Pressure is coming from several directions at once.

Populations are aging. The number of people over 65 is growing faster than the number of contributors. Birth rates remain low. Life expectancy continues to rise, even if more slowly than before. As a result, pay-as-you-go systems face a constant imbalance. To keep them functioning, governments raise contributions, cut benefits, or increase retirement ages. Most often, they use all three at the same time.

The OECD shows that lower future replacement rates are a systemic choice. This is visible in pension laws adopted in recent years. The Czech Republic has reduced future pension levels to improve financial sustainability. Japan raised contribution ceilings but adjusted indexation to demographic realities. Ireland and Korea increased contributions, yet future pensions will still fall short of past standards. These are not temporary measures. They represent a new calibration. The gap between generations is especially striking.

In many countries, current retirees receive a higher share of their previous income than those who will retire in 20–30 years. The OECD states this explicitly. Future retirees will be in a weaker position, even if they have full and uninterrupted careers.

For low-income workers, the picture looks different but no less complex. On average, future replacement rates for workers earning about half of the average wage are higher and reach around 76%. This looks like protection for vulnerable groups. But behind this figure lies redistribution. Basic and minimum pensions, top-ups, and social transfers. These tools reduce the risk of poverty, but they do not preserve living standards. Pensions become a safety anchor, not a continuation of income.

The OECD highlights another important point. Comparing replacement rates across countries can be misleading. A high rate does not always mean a generous system. Sometimes it reflects low wages during working life or strong redistribution. A low rate does not always signal failure. In some cases, it reflects a stronger reliance on private savings and work at older ages. Still, the overall direction is clear. The public pension component is shrinking.

The report also looks closely at the structure of old-age incomes. In most countries, public pensions remain the main source of income in retirement. But their share is declining. In several economies, private and occupational schemes are becoming more important. This is where new inequality emerges. Access to these schemes is uneven. It depends on sector, employment type, and income level. Those with stable careers in the formal sector benefit. Others are left with basic pensions.

The OECD does not dramatize the issue, but the implications are clear. Pension systems are no longer smoothing differences in living standards across working lives. Instead, they increasingly lock in inequalities accumulated over a lifetime. This applies to gender gaps, education levels, and employment status.

Falling replacement rates are closely linked to another trend. People spend more years in retirement. Even with slower gains in life expectancy, time spent after retirement is longer. This means accumulated resources must be spread over a longer period. If contributions and economic growth do not keep pace, annual benefits inevitably fall.

The OECD shows that many countries have built this mechanism directly into pension formulas. Indexation is increasingly linked to prices rather than wages, or to mixed indicators. This slows benefit growth in real terms. In the short run, the effect may be barely noticeable. Over time, it significantly lowers replacement rates.

The report pays special attention to the concept of pension wealth. This is the total value of expected pension payments over the entire retirement period. Even if the replacement rate looks modest, pension wealth can be high if benefits are paid for many years. But for future generations, the shift is visible here as well. Pension wealth for average earners is declining or growing much more slowly than before. This is another sign of a new balance.

Scenario comparisons make the picture more worrying. Even short career breaks sharply reduce future pensions. A five-year interruption due to unemployment or childcare leads to a noticeable drop in benefits. Ten years makes the effect much stronger. The system has become less forgiving. It smooths life paths less than it used to.

The OECD also looks separately at the self-employed. In many countries, their pension entitlements are much lower than those of employees. In some economies, replacement rates for the self-employed are only a fraction of what employees receive. This adds to the overall picture. Labor markets are changing. Non-standard work is growing. Pension systems are not always keeping up. As a result, future pensions for these workers are even lower.

All of this fits into a broader context. Pension policy is no longer designed to support the middle class. It is increasingly focused on preventing poverty. The OECD shows that many countries are strengthening first-tier pensions and targeted benefits. This reduces inequality among older people, but it does not prevent income declines for large parts of the population.

This is where the report is most revealing. It does not promise a return to the old model. On the contrary, it makes clear that future pensions will be lower relative to wages than those of today’s retirees. This is not due to poor management. It reflects structural constraints. Demographics, labor markets, and fiscal limits.

Lower replacement rates are also linked to a greater role for work at older ages. The OECD repeatedly notes that employment after the statutory retirement age is becoming an important income source. In some countries, this is already normal. Pensions and wages are combined. But this model is not available to everyone. It requires good health, skills, and labor demand. Where these conditions are missing, low replacement rates directly translate into lower living standards.

The report also highlights regional differences. In countries with a strong role for private pensions, public replacement rates are lower but are expected to be offset by savings. In countries where public systems dominate, lower replacement rates mean a more direct drop in income. There is no single solution. But the overall direction is shared.

The OECD avoids crisis language. There is no talk of collapse or breakdown. Instead, it speaks of adaptation. But for people, this adaptation feels like a loss. A loss of the familiar idea of old age. A loss of confidence that pensions will preserve social status.

For an expert audience, the key conclusion is clear. Pensions are no longer designed to replace wages. They are designed to provide a minimum income. Everything else is pushed outside the system. This is the new normal.

OECD Pensions at a Glance 2025 documents this shift calmly and consistently. Behind the charts and tables lies a change in the social contract. Governments no longer promise a comfortable retirement. They promise a sustainable system. And the price of sustainability is lower replacement rates.

Sultan Valikhanov, expert of the EconomyKZ.org portal

Scroll to Top