Kazakhstan’s banking system has gone through another reality check. AQR 2025, the regular asset quality review carried out by the Agency for Regulation and Development of the Financial Market, covered 11 of the country’s largest banks. Together, they account for 86 percent of total assets and 87 percent of the loan book. This is not a sample and not an experiment. It is almost the entire banking system in one snapshot. That is why the results give a much more honest picture than glossy financial reports.
The main takeaway is straightforward. Kazakhstan’s banks are generally stable. But this stability comes at a cost. Capital levels are comfortable, yet they still rely on banks’ own, often softer, risk views. The regulator consistently tightens those views. AQR is no longer just a supervisory exercise. It is a tool that forces banks to face risk as it is.
Total debt included in the review reached KZT 32.8 trillion. Over the year, it grew by almost 20 percent. Growth came from both on-balance loans and off-balance commitments. The average conversion factor for off-balance items was revised to 39.7 percent. As a result, the calculated risk exposure increased noticeably. In simple terms, commitments once seen as conditional now put real pressure on capital.
Capital adequacy under AQR stood at 17.7 percent. This is well above minimum requirements. Still, compared with banks’ own figures, it was 0.8 percentage points lower. The gap may look small, but at system level it means hundreds of billions of tenge. It shows that banks still tend to underplay risk, especially when loan books expand.
Loan quality has improved overall, but unevenly. Stage 3 loans, the problem assets, made up 8.7 percent under AQR. Banks reported 7.5 percent. The 1.2 percentage point gapreflects loans that were not fully recognized as impaired. At the same time, compared with AQR 2024, the share of Stage 3 fell by 1.1 percentage points. This points to ongoing cleanup through repayments, write-offs, and restructuring.
Stage 2 loans, where risk is rising but default has not happened, increased from 3.3 percent to 3.5 percent. The change is modest, but the signal matters. The regulator prefers to flag risk early rather than wait for default. In total, banks understated credit impairment by about 1.3 percent of total exposure.
The most sensitive part of the review is provisions. At the start of 2025, banks had set aside KZT 1.9 trillion. Under AQR, the required level was KZT 2.3 trillion. The gap reached KZT 377.4 billion, almost one fifth of existing provisions. Compared with last year, the gap narrowed by KZT 37.7 billion, but it remains large.
Most additional provisions relate to Stage 3 loans, nearly KZT 192 billion. Stage 2 required about KZT 46 billion, while Stage 1 added roughly KZT 140 billion. Almost one third of all adjustments came from large, individually assessed borrowers. With exposures of that size, even small errors hit capital directly.
Portfolio structure highlights the main weak spots. About one third of total debt sits in unsecured consumer loans. Their volume reached KZT 11 trillion. This segment drove the biggest increase in additional provisions. Compared with AQR 2024, adjustments here rose by more than KZT 60 billion. The reason is not just higher lending. Lower recoveries, revised default probabilities, and a single default definition all played a role.
Auto loans and other secured retail products also grew, both in size and risk. Mortgage loans backed by housing look more stable in terms of default probability. But losses remain sensitive due to how collateral is actually sold. The regulator relies on real recovery data, not appraised values. This often leads to tougher results than banks expect.
The corporate segment looks more resilient overall. Investment loans stand out. Additional provisions there fell by more than KZT 60 billion. Banks improved how they use recovery data, and default risk dropped for several large projects.
At the same time, small business loans remain among the riskiest segments. Stage 3 loans reached 11.8 percent here. That is higher than in most retail portfolios. High inflation and tight monetary conditions in 2024 hit small businesses hardest, and AQR makes this clear.
The sector view adds more detail. The largest reclassifications into worse stages came from manufacturing and other industries, totaling over KZT 200 billion. This is not an industry crisis, but it shows where pressure was strongest.
A separate part of the report focuses on large borrowers assessed individually. These are loans above 0.2 percent of a bank’s capital. The group includes 1,299 borrowers, plus 580 co-borrowers and guarantors. Their total exposure reached KZT 9.9 trillion, up 2.8 percent year on year. The gap in provisions narrowed from KZT 124 billion to KZT 107 billion. Accuracy improved, but full alignment is still not there.
For these large loans, provision coverage needs to rise from 4.9 percent to 6 percent. In Stage 3, coverage should increase by almost 5 percentage points. Even the biggest borrowers still carry risk that is not fully reflected.
Data quality remains a separate issue. The report lists problems openly. Technical errors, weak methods, confusion between write-offs and repayments, different default definitions, and thin data on off-balance items. All of this exists. Yet there is clear progress. Data quality improved compared with last year. Banks now prepare for AQR in advance and treat it as a permanent control, not a one-off event.
For the first time, the report gives a detailed view by bank. The picture varies. Some banks focus almost entirely on retail. Others rely more on corporate and individually assessed loans. Some face visible provision adjustments, others much less. This transparency makes comparisons easier and limits room for cosmetic reporting.
In the end, AQR 2025 shows a more mature supervisory system. Kazakhstan’s banking sector is not overloaded with risk. But it is far from relaxed. Lending continues, under tighter control. Understating risk now hits capital directly. And that, judging by this report, is becoming the new normal.
Alen Serik, expert of the portal EconomyKZ.org


