In 2025, the National Bank of Kazakhstan released one of its most notable analytical papers in recent years – “Modeling the Term Premium in Kazakhstan Using the ACM Model.”
Behind this technical title lies an important story about how the market perceives time, risk, and the future.
Over the past three years, yields on government securities have been rising. At first glance, this looks like a natural reaction to higher inflation and a tighter monetary policy. But the study shows that something deeper is happening. The key driver is not just the base rate – it’s the market’s expectations. Investors are trying to protect themselves against uncertainty, and this “insurance” takes the form of the term premium.
The paper, authored by Bauyrzhan Shamar, analyst at the NBK’s Monetary Policy Department, applies the Adrian–Crump–Moench (ACM) methodology – a globally recognized approach for separating bond yields into two components: the neutral long-term rate and the term premium, the extra compensation investors demand for holding long-term bonds.
Previously, Kazakhstan’s neutral rate was estimated using the NBK Macroeconomic Survey, where market experts provided their expectations. Those estimates usually ranged from 8% to 9%, while 10-year government bond yields stood at 14–15%. The gap was striking – it reflected risk, uncertainty, and the structural features of the local bond market. The ACM model made it possible to quantify this difference using only market data, without relying on surveys or subjective opinions.
The results are telling. According to the model, Kazakhstan’s neutral nominal long-term rate stands between 9% and 9.2%, closely matching survey results but calculated in a more consistent and objective way. The term premium, meanwhile, has increased sharply since 2022, signaling higher perceived risk among investors.
During 2020–2021, the term premium remained stable. But as inflation accelerated and monetary policy tightened, it began to climb. In 2025, the premium for 10-year bonds remains elevated, meaning investors now demand a larger cushion against uncertainty – from inflation expectations to fiscal risks and market liquidity constraints.
The NBK study highlights that Kazakhstan’s bond market has its own specifics. It is less liquid, more segmented, and strongly influenced by short-term policy rates. New bond issues often anchor to the latest base rate rather than macroeconomic fundamentals. As a result, the long end of the yield curve reflects not only expectations but also technical and behavioral effects.
The ACM model works in three stages. First, it extracts the main factors that shape bond prices – the level, slope, and curvature of the yield curve. Second, it measures how these factors affect yields of different maturities. Third, it estimates the price of risk – the part of yield that compensates investors for uncertainty. This statistical process allows economists to separate what the market “expects” from what it “fears.”
The findings are clear: even when short-term policy appears stable, investors remain cautious about the long term. The further into the future, the greater the uncertainty. For emerging markets like Kazakhstan, this sensitivity is especially strong due to thinner liquidity and higher volatility.
One major advantage of the ACM approach is that it allows monthly estimation of the neutral rate, going back to late 2019. By comparison, the NBK’s Macroeconomic Survey began only in August 2022 and is conducted eight times per year. This makes the ACM-based results more dynamic and data-rich.
However, the author also notes the limitations. The ACM model is purely statistical – it does not explain economic causes, only captures relationships between numbers. To interpret the results meaningfully, additional analysis is required. In advanced economies, researchers often combine ACM data with VAR or DSGE models to identify which macroeconomic factors truly drive the term premium. Kazakhstan is only starting to move in this direction.
Even so, the study uncovers several important patterns. The term premium closely follows movements in TONIA, Kazakhstan’s interbank overnight rate – the NBK’s main operational target. When TONIA rises, the term premium tends to follow with a lag. This suggests that new bond issues are heavily influenced by short-term rate changes rather than long-term fundamentals.
Other domestic factors, such as inflation and the Composite Economic Indicator (CEI), show weaker correlation. Yet starting in 2024, inflation and the term premium began moving in the same direction, implying that rising prices push investors to demand higher compensation for risk.
Among global variables, the study highlights the importance of the VIX and EMBI indices – both common measures of international risk sentiment. Periods of high global volatility coincide with surges in Kazakhstan’s term premium. The message is simple: Kazakhstan’s bond market is sensitive to global uncertainty.
Using a basic VAR(1) model, the NBK also examined how the term premium reacts to macro and external factors such as seasonally adjusted inflation, the CEI, TONIA, EMBI, CDS spreads, and Brent oil prices. The results show that short-term effects are statistically significant, but long-term impulse responses remain weak. In other words, more complex modeling is needed to explain the full dynamics of the premium.
The conclusion is straightforward yet meaningful. The neutral long-term nominal rate in Kazakhstan is estimated between 9–9.2%, confirming but refining earlier assessments. The term premium for 10-year bonds has risen since 2022, driven by both supply-demand imbalances and inflation-related risks. This makes the ACM model a valuable new instrument for understanding how monetary policy transmits through Kazakhstan’s bond market.
More broadly, the research bridges theory and practice. By adapting an international methodology to local data, the NBK now has a reliable tool for gauging market expectations and confidence in real time. It can measure how much of a bond yield reflects policy expectations – and how much reflects fear of the unknown.
For policymakers, this matters. The term premium serves as a mirror of trust. When investors believe in stability, the premium shrinks. When uncertainty rises, it expands. In Kazakhstan’s case, the increase since 2022 shows that markets are pricing in caution – a normal stage in the evolution of a maturing financial system.
The author recommends expanding future research to include factors such as the share of foreign investors, global risk indices, and liquidity cycles. Adding these parameters could improve the model’s accuracy and better capture real-world conditions.
Another strength of the ACM approach is its reliance solely on market data – no survey bias, no subjective judgment. The market itself tells the story.
The key question, then, is why the premium keeps rising. If a 10-year bond yields 15%, while the neutral rate is 9%, the 6-percentage-point gap is the market’s price for uncertainty. The higher the gap, the greater the caution – and the higher the cost of long-term borrowing for the government.
In this sense, the term premium is more than a technical measure. It’s a psychological barometer of the market – a snapshot of how confidence and caution balance out.
Kazakhstan’s recent experience illustrates this perfectly. In 2020–2021, the premium was low, signaling comfort and predictability. From 2022 onward, global volatility and domestic inflation changed that picture. By 2025, the premium reached new highs, mirroring the global pattern of risk repricing.
The NBK’s study doesn’t sound alarmist, though. It shows that the rise in the term premium is a natural reaction to uncertainty. As inflation stabilizes and liquidity improves, the premium could gradually decline.
What makes this research especially valuable is its transparency. All calculations are based on an open methodology – no “black box.” This means that analysts, investors, and academics can use the results independently.
Unlike expert surveys, which capture opinions, the ACM model captures what the market itself believes. That’s its biggest advantage.
Kazakhstan’s inclusion in the global ACM research landscape is also noteworthy. Since its introduction in 2013, the Adrian–Crump–Moench method has been used in the United States, the euro area, Australia, Turkey, New Zealand, and beyond. Now, Kazakhstan joins that list, applying a proven global model to local data.
Internationally, the ACM framework helps central banks evaluate monetary policy transmission, inflation expectations, and term structure dynamics. For Kazakhstan, it represents a step toward data-driven policymaking and deeper integration of economic research into decision-making.
Technically, the model uses five principal components – level, slope, curvature, and two higher-order factors – that describe the shape of the yield curve. Each factor reflects a different aspect of market sentiment. When the level rises, rates across maturities move higher. When the slope changes, it shows shifting expectations about growth and policy.
Ultimately, the study paints a new picture of Kazakhstan’s bond market. The term premium emerges not as a side effect of inflation but as a standalone measure of confidence and risk.
For the central bank, this provides a clearer view of how its actions influence long-term rates. For investors, it helps assess whether current yields adequately compensate for uncertainty.
In this way, the NBK’s research transforms a complex mathematical framework into a practical policy tool. It bridges statistical modeling with the real dynamics of trust, risk, and expectation.
Future refinements – such as accounting for foreign participation, global uncertainty indices, and liquidity conditions – will make the analysis even stronger. But even in its current form, the study answers one key question: why do long-term yields in Kazakhstan remain higher than neutral rates? The answer lies in the term premium – the market’s price for time and uncertainty.
Rather than a negative sign, this is evidence of a maturing market. As investors become more sophisticated and risk-aware, they demand compensation for uncertainty. That’s a normal and even healthy development.
Sultan Valikhanov, expert of the EconomyKZ.org portal


