In 2012, Turkey launched its most ambitious regional subsidy program. The aim was to close the gap between the country’s wealthy western provinces and the less developed east and southeast. On the micro level, the results were striking: firms boosted revenues, hired more workers, and improved productivity. But the bigger question was whether the policy reduced inequality across the country.
The data tells a mixed story. In the short run, subsidies narrowed the gap. In the long run, however, the effect fades, leaving Turkey still divided.
In the first years after the program began, the results looked promising. Researchers’ models show that wage differences between regions shrank by 6.9%. Eastern provinces saw new jobs, faster income growth, and more opportunities for residents to stay put rather than migrate to Istanbul or Izmir. For Turkey, this was a breakthrough. For decades, the country had struggled with east-to-west migration that overloaded big cities and deepened inequality.
Looking further ahead, the optimism fades. By 2036, according to general equilibrium modeling, the reduction in regional inequality is expected to be only 3–4%. In other words, the long-run impact is roughly half of the short-term gain.
Two fundamental forces explain the decline:
1. Labor mobility.
Even when new jobs are created in poorer regions, many workers still move to richer provinces. Higher wages, better services, and greater career opportunities pull people west. The gains from subsidies partly flow to Istanbul, Ankara, and other large centers.
2. Trade linkages.
New factories in the east sell much of their output to western markets. Jobs may stay local, but profits concentrate in wealthier regions. Together, these factors dilute the impact of subsidies.
The program slowed outmigration from the east. People had more reasons to stay thanks to new jobs. This eased some of the pressure on Istanbul, which had long struggled with overpopulation and strained infrastructure. But migration did not stop. For many families, moving west remained the rational choice. Subsidies softened the trend, but they did not reverse it.
If the results were drawn as a chart, it would look like this:
• 2012–2015: the inequality line drops sharply. The gap narrows by almost 7%.
• 2020–2025: the decline slows, the curve flattens. Migration and trade start to erode the progress.
• 2030–2036: the line levels off. Inequality falls by just 3–4% compared to the start.
A fast start, but weak results over time.
Turkey’s experience shows that subsidies can soften inequality but cannot eliminate it. The reasons are structural:
• regions are deeply integrated into the national economy;
• workers move where opportunities are better;
• only a small share of firms could access subsidies (just 2.5% of those eligible completed projects).
In short, the program boosted part of the economy but did not transform the country as a whole.
Subsidies were useful, but not enough. Sustainable regional development requires more:
• investment in transport and logistics infrastructure;
• improvements in education and training;
• a better business climate so firms can thrive without constant state support.
Only a broader set of reforms can turn short-term gains into long-term convergence.
Turkey’s subsidy program delivered mixed results. In the short run, it reduced inequality, created jobs, and gave eastern provinces a boost. But over decades, the effect is limited. By 2036, regional disparities will shrink only slightly. Industrial policy, then, is not a silver bullet. Subsidies help, but real convergence requires deeper reforms and long-term investment.
Alen Serik, expert of the portal EconomyKZ.org


