EC[ON]OMY

Transforming governance in Kazakhstan: embracing transparency

Kazakhstan today faces growing challenges that require the government system to find new, more efficient, and transparent models of interaction with business and society. Global experience offers several proven examples where the private sector not only contributes to the economy but also acts as a guarantor of legality, quality, and proper execution of public tasks – while creating new sources of budget revenue.

1.⁠ ⁠Lobbying within the Law (International Experience)

In the United States, Canada, Australia, and an increasing number of European countries, lobbying is a legitimate and regulated profession.

Lobbyists – whether individuals or organizations – must register with an authorized body, such as the U.S. Congress or a national registry. Essentially, they are licensed professionals.

This system makes lobbying fully transparent. Lobbyists are required to regularly report on their clients, lobbying goals (for example, promoting bills, obtaining benefits or state contracts, or securing business permits), and on the income they receive – which is subject to taxation.

In this way, a lobbyist becomes a public intermediary whose legal activity helps reduce corruption risks. In the context of doing business, a registered lobbyist working under the lobbying law ensures that all promoted interests – such as licensing or preferential treatment – are pursued through lawful means. The registration and reporting requirements ensure that influence on decision-making happens within a legal and transparent framework, not through informal or corrupt channels.

Relevance for Kazakhstan

Legalizing and strictly regulating lobbying – especially in areas related to starting and running a business – could become a powerful tool against corruption in Kazakhstan. Instead of solving issues informally or behind closed doors, businesses would gain the opportunity to promote their interests openly, professionally, and lawfully, while paying taxes that contribute to the state budget.

In essence, this approach shifts hidden influence into a framework of public accountability.

2.⁠ ⁠Outsourcing City Management (U.S. Experience)

In some smaller U.S. towns and municipalities, local governments operate with a minimal number of officials and hire private management companies to handle day-to-day operations.

The administration provides the management company with a fixed budget and a contractual obligation to implement the city’s master plan – covering everything from landscaping to public utilities.

The management company is then responsible for delivering all services on time and with quality. Its profit and contract renewal depend directly on measurable results: clean streets, repaired roads, and progress on development goals. Importantly, the main evaluators are the residents themselves, and their feedback influences administrative decisions.

Engaging a private company with expertise in engineering and management helps raise professional standards and reduce bureaucratic inefficiency.

Relevance for Kazakhstan

This model is particularly suitable for small regional towns in Kazakhstan. Transferring management of utilities, infrastructure maintenance, and parts of the general development plan to private companies (under strict budgetary control and oversight from the akimat) would:

  • ⁠ ⁠optimize public spending and staffing costs;
  • ⁠ ⁠improve service quality, as private companies are motivated by profit and reputation;
  • ⁠ ⁠assign clear responsibility to the contractor, eliminating situations where public officials avoid accountability.

3.⁠ ⁠Delegating Supervisory and Inspection Functions (EU Experience)

In many EU countries, especially in fields such as technical regulation, certification, and financial auditing, governments have delegated some supervisory functions to private, accredited, and licensed organizations.

Government agencies may authorize private companies to perform inspections, ensure compliance with safety standards, or conduct initial financial reviews. These private entities then carry full legal and financial responsibility for their conclusions.

Essentially, such companies act as guarantors of lawful and safe business practices in their specific sectors. For instance, a private certification body ensures that products meet safety requirements and is legally accountable for any violations.

This approach allows the government to offload routine control tasks and focus instead on strategic regulation and oversight of the private controllers themselves.

Relevance for Kazakhstan

Kazakhstan could successfully apply this model in areas requiring strong technical expertise, such as:

  • ⁠ ⁠construction supervision (with increased accountability for private engineers);
  • ⁠ ⁠product certification and standardization;
  • ⁠ ⁠environmental auditing and monitoring of large industrial sites.

This would improve the quality of oversight (as private entities are often more skilled and motivated) and transfer risk and responsibility from the state to private guarantors who bear both financial and reputational consequences for their actions.

Common Success Factors across All Three Cases

  1. Source of Guarantees – Responsibility for legality, quality, and performance is shifted fromgovernment officials to private entities. This makes accountabilitymeasurable, enforceable, and financially binding.
  2. Fiscal Effect – Legal mechanisms such as lobbying, contracts, and delegated controlcreate additional tax revenue from private entities operating in thesefields.
  3. Transparency andAccountability – Official registration, licensing, and reporting reduce corruption risks andbring formerly opaque processes into the public sphere.
  4. Professionalization – Involving the private sector increases expertise and improves the qualityof public services – from city management to technical supervision.

Recommendations for Implementation in Kazakhstan

1.⁠ ⁠Lobbying:

  • ⁠ ⁠Develop and adopt a lobbying law modeled on Anglo-Saxon systems;
  • ⁠ ⁠Introduce a mandatory and open registry of lobbyists under Parliament and/or the Ministry of Justice;
  • ⁠ ⁠Legally define lobbying as the sole legitimate mechanism for influencing legislation, investment policies, and business regulation – eliminating informal and corruption-prone practices.

2.⁠ ⁠Outsourced City Management:

  • ⁠ ⁠Amend laws to allow local governments (akimats) to sign management contracts for implementing parts of city development plans;
  • ⁠ ⁠Pilot this model in 1–2 small towns (10,000–50,000 residents, third-tier budgets), transferring utilities, public works, and technical oversight to private companies with clear KPIs and penalties for non-performance.

3.⁠ ⁠Delegated Oversight:

  • ⁠ ⁠Strengthen the role of accreditation and licensing institutions;
  • ⁠ ⁠Transfer parts of construction supervision and environmental monitoring to accredited private entities, establishing mandatory insurance and financial liability for their reports;
  • ⁠ ⁠Refocus state agencies on monitoring these private controllers for impartiality and competence.

All three approaches share a common vision: building a more professional, transparent, and accountable system of governance – one where the private sector becomes a responsible partner in ensuring the rule of law, efficiency, and economic growth in Kazakhstan.

Daulet Zhambaybekov, independent expert, specifically for www.economyKZ.org

Scroll to Top