EC[ON]OMY

Transforming academic growth for young researchers

Kazakhstan has grants and support programs for young researchers. But the system still struggles to produce truly competitive scientists. The issue is not a lack of talent, and not only about funding. The real gap is the absence of a clear, structured path for academic growth.

A scientific career without a roadmap

Today, a young researcher moves in fragments: Master’s – PhD – postdoc – teaching. On paper, the stages exist. In reality, there is no real connection between them. Entry and exit points are unclear. A student does not know when and how they can join a lab. A supervisor does not know when to let a trained researcher move on and become independent.

In Kazakhstan’s academic culture, there is a strange belief that real science starts only after a Master’s degree. Before that, students are supposed to “just study.” This model is outdated. At leading universities worldwide, undergraduate students join labs from their first year. They work as full members of research teams, with real tasks and co-authorship in publications. In Kazakhstan, this is still rare.

By the time our students enter a Master’s program, many have no idea how a scientific paper is created, how a hypothesis is shaped, or how reviewers tear a manuscript apart. And suddenly we expect them, within two years of a Master’s and three years of a PhD, to become independent researchers.

That is unrealistic. You cannot learn to swim by reading textbooks.

Supervisors: start taking students now

This requires a serious shift in mindset. Too often, professors wait for students who are already “prepared” – with research skills, methodological knowledge, and experience working with academic literature. But where is a second-year student supposed to get that experience if no one brings them into a project early on?

Stop ignoring students and waiting for them to train themselves. Recruit them into research teams in their first or second year, even if they have minimal skills and zero understanding of what science really is. That is how talent is built. Not by selecting the already polished, but by creating the conditions for growth.

Yes, it takes time. Yes, in the first months, a student will bring more questions than value. Yes, it is easier to assign tasks to a doctoral student who already knows the process. But if a professor does not make this early investment, five years later they will once again complain that there are “no достойные candidates for doctoral programs.”

Create positions in your labs for undergraduates. Give them real tasks, not fake ones. Let them attend seminars, read papers, try writing their first reviews. This is the only way to eventually get a well-prepared Master’s student who can grow into a strong PhD.

Early publications are not “Too early” – they are “on time”

Involving students in publication projects from the early years is a fundamental training tool. First, it filters motivation. Real interest in science shows up when a student is willing to spend an evening in the lab figuring out why an experiment failed. A student who goes through every stage of a paper – from literature review to responding to reviewers – quickly understands whether they truly want a research career. Second, it builds research thinking. Critical thinking develops through practice. When your hypothesis is rejected by data. When you realize that three months of work are useless because the methodology was flawed. This experience hurts, but it is irreplaceable. Third, it integrates students into the scientific community. A student with a publication in a peer-reviewed journal enters a Master’s program with a completely different status. They speak the language of science. They have the beginning of a reputation. They are not a “test subject” in graduate school, but a junior colleague with potential. At Western universities, undergraduate research programs are standard. In Kazakhstan, they exist only occasionally, without systemic support.

No generational renewal and weak horizontal links

Kazakhstan’s science also faces a serious generational issue. Weak horizontal ties between labs and universities mean that each supervisor has to train people from scratch. Graduates who are ready for independent work often leave the system because there are no transparent mechanisms for moving between research groups. There is no culture of passing a well-trained student from one mentor to another. No network model where a young researcher can gain experience across different teams.

PhD quotas: when quantity kills quality

Another serious issue is the rigid linkage between grant funding programs and fixed quantitative targets for PhD graduates. When research grants require a project to “produce” a certain number of PhDs, the focus shifts from scientific results to formal indicators. It is important not to confuse cause and effect.

The 2010-2011 reform, when Kazakhstan moved from the Soviet system to the international PhD model, was a step in the right direction. The Law on Science introduced new standards, academic titles such as associate professor and professor were updated, and the goal was clear – remove случайные people and raise quality. The idea behind the PhD model was deeper research, real scientific contribution, and international integration. The problem came later, when implementation turned into quotas.

In the rush to increase the number of state-funded PhDs, the system began operating like a factory: fixed deadlines, fixed numbers of graduates, strict performance indicators. Imagine the mechanism. A researcher receives a large grant. The funding terms state: “Train 5 PhD students in this field.” If, after three years, the researcher produces two excellent PhDs with strong dissertations but misses the quota, the project is considered underperformed. If they graduate five weak candidates, formally everything is fine.

The indicators are closed. What happens next? A hunt for doctoral candidates begins. People who are not ready for research apply, attracted by a stipend and salary. They fulfill the formal presence requirement, but do not grow as researchers.

In some cases, supervisors end up writing dissertations themselves, while doctoral students simply sign the final text. The defense becomes a necessity not for academic growth, but to avoid financial penalties and sanctions. After three years, statistics show five new PhDs. But science has not advanced even a millimeter.

Graduates hold internationally recognized degrees on paper, but lack real research skills. They cannot formulate their own hypothesis or defend it in front of the scientific community. Instead of raising quality, the quota system created a new form of formal “mass production” inside the international model. Worse, quotas kill risk.

Real science is always risky. A hypothesis may fail. An experiment may produce unexpected results. A research direction may turn out to be a dead end. In a healthy scientific environment, that is normal. A failed project still removes a false path. But if you are required to guarantee five PhD graduates, you cannot afford risky research. You choose safe, predictable topics. You stop being a researcher and become a conveyor manager.

Mentorship instead of management

A project leader should be a mentor, not a quota controller. Their role is to help a young researcher grow, not to ensure that a formal plan is checked off. This requires time and a reduction of administrative pressure on leading scientists. Kazakhstan cannot afford the luxury of “producing” doctors for reporting purposes. The country needs world-class researchers. You cannot grow them by template or by quota.

Only by abandoning the quota-based PhD model and by systematically involving students in real research from early undergraduate years can we build a true ecosystem – one that grows scientists, not just numbers in a table.

Bakhytzhan Sariev, PhD, Assistant Professor at Astana IT University,
specifically for www.economyKZ.org

Scroll to Top