EC[ON]OMY

The hidden costs of targeted subsidies in Kazakhstan

Targeted subsidies look like the most tempting tool of industrial policy. Money can be deployed quickly. Results are easy to showcase. One factory. One company. Thousands of jobs. But global experience shows a hard pattern: the more precise the subsidy, the higher the risk that it locks businesses into dependence on the state instead of building competitiveness. For Kazakhstan, where backing individual players has long been the norm, this risk is no longer theoretical.

Targeted support almost always starts the same way. An industry is declared strategic. A company is labeled systemically important. A project is given national priority status. Then come concessional loans, guarantees, subsidies, tax breaks, and special regimes. Politically, this is convenient. Economically, the outcome is usually far more complex than it looks at the start.

Practice shows that point support for specific firms rarely solves structural problems. It shifts focus away from productivity and technology toward access to resources. The larger the support, the more distorted incentives become. The company starts to see the state as a permanent partner, not a temporary investor. Risk is partly shifted to the budget. Moral hazard emerges, where failure no longer threatens survival.

Historical experience with targeted subsidies illustrates this logic well. Even when support helps a company survive a crisis, it rarely makes the business sustainable without further assistance. After a few years, the problem returns in a new form. Requests for help reappear. The arguments change. The essence remains the same.

Targeted subsidies are often justified by jobs. This is a powerful argument. But it becomes dangerous when it replaces efficiency assessment. If the cost of preserving one job far exceeds the average wage, the economy starts paying for symbols instead of results. At the same time, alternative ways to support employment are almost always cheaper, but they look less impressive in public policy.

Another feature of targeted support is blurred success criteria. At the start, projects promise export growth, new technologies, and global market entry. As implementation unfolds, the bar gradually drops. First, it is enough to keep production running. Then, to preserve employment. Then, simply to avoid bankruptcy. The definition of success shrinks, while the subsidy remains.

For Kazakhstan, this logic is especially sensitive. An economy with a large quasi-state sector and a limited number of major players tends to reproduce support models built around specific recipients. In such conditions, targeted measures quickly turn into a stable redistribution system rather than a growth instrument.

There is another effect that is rarely discussed openly. Targeted subsidies distort competition. Firms receiving support gain an advantage. Their costs are lower. Risks are partially removed. Other players must compete not only with the market, but with the budget. This suppresses initiative and reduces private investment inflows into the sector.

Over time, markets adapt to subsidies. Business models are designed with future support in mind. Investment decisions are made not based on demand and efficiency, but on the likelihood of receiving aid. This undermines the very idea of industrial policy as a tool for competitiveness.

Targeted support also brings another problem. The state becomes involved in operational decisions. The more money invested, the stronger the urge to control processes. Approvals, conditions, and restrictions multiply. Business flexibility declines. Market response slows. The firm ends up both shielded from competition and burdened by oversight.

In global practice, the few cases of relative success with targeted subsidies share one feature. Support was time-limited. Conditions were strict. Management autonomy was high. The state did not act as a permanent donor. Once the business reached a stable trajectory, support ended.

This element, however, is what most often disappears in real policy. Politically, it is harder to withdraw support than to introduce it. Every project accumulates arguments about strategic importance, supply chains, and social risks. As a result, a temporary measure becomes permanent.

In Kazakhstan, this problem is amplified by weak exit mechanisms. It is easy to write goals into documents. It is much harder to prescribe automatic termination of support when goals are missed. Without such mechanisms, any targeted subsidy becomes a long-term budget obligation.

The technological effect is another issue. Targeted subsidies rarely generate breakthroughs. They more often support existing production chains. Innovation emerges where competition, market pressure, and access to knowledge exist. Subsidies reduce that pressure. As a result, technological progress slows.

For Kazakhstan, this means the risk of being locked into supporting established players without renewing the industrial structure. New companies face entry barriers. Old ones gain advantages. Economic dynamism fades.

There is also a fiscal dimension. Targeted subsidies are hard to fully assess in advance. Their real cost grows over time. Beyond direct spending, there are indirect losses through price distortions, tax exemptions, and guarantees. These costs rarely appear in public balance sheets, but they affect fiscal sustainability.

Industrial policy built around individual champions always balances between strategy and lobbying. The weaker the institutional safeguards, the higher the risk that decisions are made for specific beneficiaries rather than sector-wide goals.

In Kazakhstan’s context, the key question is not whether subsidies are needed. The question is their design. If support is not accompanied by hard contractual conditions, measurable indicators, and clawback mechanisms, it almost inevitably creates moral hazard.

Global experience shows that the most resilient support models avoid picking individual winners. They focus on ecosystems, research, standards, and infrastructure. Where the state funds knowledge rather than corporate balance sheets, distortion risks are lower.

Targeted subsidies can only make sense as part of a broader framework. They should be the exception, not the rule. Otherwise, industrial policy starts working against itself.

For Kazakhstan, this means rethinking a familiar approach. Supporting one large project often looks like quick success. But in the long run, it reduces pressure for efficiency and deepens dependence on the budget. The economy gains not growth, but a pause.

Moral hazard rarely appears overnight. It accumulates. First through soft conditions. Then through extensions. Then through new aid packages. At some point, it becomes clear that the company cannot survive without support. Admitting this, however, is politically difficult.

Industrial policy built around one champion always looks simpler than systemic reform. But only systemic solutions deliver durable results. Targeted measures almost always require constant follow-up and new injections.

Kazakhstan needs to keep this experience in mind because resources are limited. Every tenge directed to one player is a tenge not invested in building an environment where dozens of new companies could grow. It is a choice between short-term stability and long-term dynamism.

Lina Yegil kizi, expert of the EconomyKZ.org portal

Scroll to Top