Each year, Kazakhstan’s government announces a GDP growth target. The number looks ambitious and sounds promising—but what does it really mean? Often, not much. Behind these figures are inflated expectations, rising government spending, and inflationary pressure. The economy ends up driven more by reporting needs than by real productivity.
It’s time to switch from mechanical growth targets to something more meaningful. One smarter approach is using potential GDP. This concept focuses on what the economy can sustain without overheating. But using it requires careful handling—and Kazakhstan must avoid repeating past mistakes with a new label.
Right now, the government might set a target of, say, 5% GDP growth. Ministries then push the economy toward that number—regardless of how sustainable or inclusive the growth is. That leads to a dangerous illusion of control.
The current system encourages procyclical policies: when times are good, spending rises even further, potentially overheating the economy; when things get tough, spending is cut, deepening the recession. This pattern creates fiscal instability and inflationary risks.
Potential GDP is the maximum output the economy can produce without triggering inflation. It’s not directly observable but can be estimated using economic models. Its main strength: it offers a better sense of what the economy can handle over the long term.
But there’s a downside. Estimating potential GDP comes with a margin of error. That’s why it should be used alongside independent assessments and transparent forecasting methods. For Kazakhstan, this means building trust in data and methodology.
Counter-cyclical fiscal policy means moving opposite to the economic cycle: boosting spending during downturns and pulling back when the economy is strong. For example, Kazakhstan did the right thing by increasing spending during the 2020 crisis. But in 2022–2024 spending kept rising even after recovery.
That’s textbook procyclical behavior—and it’s risky. Kazakhstan needs a system where fiscal policy automatically adapts to the business cycle. Not through ad-hoc decisions, but through well-designed rules.
A structural budget balance adjusts for temporary economic ups and downs. It tells us what the budget would look like if the economy were running at full potential. This approach helps:
• Avoid overspending during booms,
• Stimulate the economy during recessions,
• Keep public debt under control.
In a resource-dependent country like Kazakhstan, this is critical. Structural balance provides a buffer against external shocks, like oil price swings.
Kazakhstan’s fiscal history is mixed:
• 2008–2009, 2015–2016, 2020 — Strong counter-cyclical responses.
• 2003–2007, 2011–2014, 2018–2019, 2022–2024 — Spending increased even during good years, pushing the budget into deficit.
Why? A lack of fiscal rules. Budget decisions were often driven by short-term needs, not long-term logic.
What Fiscal Rules Kazakhstan Needs
1. Structural Budget Rule:
◦ Allow deficit up to 3% of GDP during downturns;
◦ Aim for balance or surplus during stable periods.
2. Expenditure Growth Limit:
◦ Government spending shouldn’t grow faster than potential GDP;
◦ This curbs populism and keeps spending disciplined.
3. Public Debt Rule:
◦ Maximum debt-to-GDP ratio: 45%;
◦ At 40%: Finance Minister must report to Parliament and propose measures;
◦ At 42%: Government must adopt a debt-reduction plan;
◦ At 44%: Automatic spending cuts and next year’s budget must be balanced.
To make these rules work, Kazakhstan should create a Fiscal Rules Council. Its responsibilities:
• Estimate potential GDP,
• Monitor structural budget performance,
• Ensure transparency in forecasting,
• Advise the Finance Minister on policy.
The Council could be formed jointly by ASPIR, the Ministry of National Economy, and the National Bank. Its role would be expert-based—not political.
Kazakhstan must move beyond chasing GDP numbers for their own sake. The goal should be sustainable, balanced growth—not just hitting a growth percentage. Modern fiscal rules aren’t about bureaucracy—they’re about stability. They give governments the tools to plan beyond the election cycle and weather economic shocks.
A disciplined budget is the foundation of a resilient economy.


