EC[ON]OMY

Nothing Random About It

Institutional economist Douglass North argued that countries stuck in low-growth traps often made the wrong institutional choices early on. He illustrated this with the case of England and Spain.

By the 16th century the two countries were on fairly equal footing – similar population sizes, labor structures, and both actively expanding their influence overseas. From a macroeconomic perspective, there was no reason to think their futures would diverge significantly. Yet by the 19th century, England had become the world’s leading power, while Spain had fallen behind most of Europe.

So, what happened? North suggested it all came down to a seemingly small difference. In England decisions about taxation ended up in the hands of Parliament. In Spain they remained under the control of the king. That small institutional detail had big consequences. Spain brought in far more riches from its colonies than England, but those resources were quickly spent. Why invest in business or development when the king could seize your assets at any time?

England, by contrast, created conditions for long-term investment and capital accumulation. And while countries can realize their past mistakes fairly quickly in historical terms, changing course is a different story. Once a nation goes down a certain path, it builds layers of institutions and vested interests that resist deep reform. Spain has spent the past two centuries going through revolutions and civil wars, trying to break out of that path. Whether it has succeeded is still an open question.

Kuanysh Beisengazin, National Bureau of Economic Research,
specifically for www.economyKZ.org

Scroll to Top