EC[ON]OMY

Let’s Talk About the National Fund – At Length and In Detail

A few weeks ago I came across a thought-provoking post in one of my favorite Telegram channels, DESHT, titled “Debating the National Fund”. The author offered a sharp critique of the contradictory arguments often made about how Kazakhstan’s National Fund is used. Since this is a topic I also study closely, I decided to add my own two cents.

The issue was recently discussed at a meeting of Kazakhstan’s Expert Council on Economic Development. The broader context? Ensuring macroeconomic stability through coordination between monetary and fiscal policy.

Let’s unpack the key points:

Contradictory Logic?

The post reminds us: one of the main justifications for tightening Kazakhstan’s tax system is to protect the National Fund. We’re told not to touch the Fund, because doing so strengthens the tenge too much. Then we’re told not to lower interest rates either — because the tenge might weaken. But nowhere is it clearly stated that the exchange rate should simply be stable.

In reality, the idea isn’t to never use the Fund, but to avoid excessive, unsystematic withdrawals. Guaranteed transfers are legally fixed and part of medium-term fiscal planning. The real debate is about targeted transfers — those that fall outside any rules and depend entirely on discretionary decisions.

Spending and the Exchange Rate

To use National Fund money in the budget, dollars are exchanged for tenge — this naturally puts pressure on the currency market. As for interest rates: in theory, lowering the base rate makes the tenge weaker (and vice versa), and that’s well established in economic literature. A stable exchange rate should be the default, but in our case, the question “Why is the tenge unstable?” has become rhetorical — we all know why. Despite several industrialization programs, we haven’t achieved real economic diversification.

National Fund's Assets-to-GDP Ratio
Dynamics of the National Fund’s Assets-to-GDP Ratio

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Spending Leads to Imports

Using the Fund to boost consumption leads to higher imports and overheating. That’s also why authorities have restricted household lending. But when interest rates stay high, people’s real income drops — and with it, consumption and living standards.

Since most of what we consume is imported, fiscal multipliers in Kazakhstan are very low. Based on our empirical analysis, each extra tenge in public spending generates only 22 tiyn (cents) of GDP after a year. Why? Because the money flows out for imports rather than circulating in the local economy.

Even worse, a large share of National Fund spending goes to short-term social needs — not economic development. In 2021 according to the Supreme Audit Chamber, 57.5% of targeted transfers were used for current expenses. This trend has been growing since 2017. In fact, in 2019, 100% of targeted transfers (excluding reserve funds) went to cover ongoing costs.

How We Present the Numbers

When convenient, we use metrics like taxes as a share of GDP — to show we’re behind developed countries. But when highlighting withdrawals from the Fund, we switch to absolute tenge figures — and often don’t even adjust for inflation. If we did stick to GDP comparisons, there hasn’t been much change in Fund withdrawals over the past 15 years. In fact, they’ve improved.

From 2010 to 2021 Kazakhstan withdrew 31.9 trillion tenge from the Fund — more than the 30.7 trillion tenge in oil tax revenue received. That means we took out more than we put in.

Absolute numbers do matter here. Comparing Fund withdrawals to GDP serves one purpose (structural analysis), while absolute amounts serve another (fiscal balance and sustainability).

DESHT notes that over 2015–2023 the National Fund transfers covered around 30% of the national budget on average. That share dropped to 19% in 2023 – but this doesn’t mean things are improving.

Unfortunately, Fund assets relative to GDP declined from 28% in 2021 to 23% in 2023. Under the old Budget Rule (pre-2022), transfers should’ve stopped when assets dropped below 30% of GDP. But the new 2030 Strategy lowered the threshold to 20%. We’re almost there already.

National Fund's Funds-to-Republican Budget Ratio
Dynamics of the National Fund’s Funds-to-Republican Budget Ratio, in billion tenge

Comparing Realities, Not Ideals

Economic debates often compare reality to ideal worlds: “If only we saved more, we’d have $196 billion in the Fund,” or “in case of crisis, it could support the economy for a year.” But economics is about weighing real-world alternatives — not daydreaming.

Given that 30–40% of our economy is tied to exports, mostly oil, which funds the National Fund — can we really avoid using it? Probably not. But that also means oil volatility should limithow much we withdraw.

If we keep using resource income for day-to-day spending, what will we do when the oil dries up or prices fall? The real question isn’t “Should we withdraw from the Fund?” but rather: When? For what purpose? And how much?

What About Infrastructure and Kids?

Yes, Kazakhstan’s infrastructure is outdated and costly to maintain. But using the Fund for every repair is not the answer. In many cases, money went not to long-term upgrades but short-term patchwork — without real productivity gains. In 2022, investments in electricity and water infrastructure fell, even though over 70% of the grid is worn out.

As for children: 33% of the population is now under 18 — over 6.5 million kids. That’s a huge demographic factor. Thankfully, a special mechanism now directs part of the Fund’s assets directly to support children, so this concern may already be addressed.

No Need to Fear Reform

We shouldn’t fear that reforms will be rolled back. Budget imbalances aren’t going anywhere, and neither are fiscal conservatives. But reforms can be derailed if they spark mass dissatisfaction.

“Just sit and save” isn’t much of a strategy either. Economies don’t pause. If we stop moving, we stagnate — like the U.S. during the Great Depression.

And let’s be honest: future generations won’t thank us for a frozen offshore fund. They’d rather inherit a strong legal system, good infrastructure, and diverse economic opportunities.

The Bottom Line

I fully agree. Reforms require public trust and courage — otherwise even good ideas fail. Our goal isn’t to leave behind just a “rainy day fund,” but a healthy, functioning economy.

That’s why the National Fund must not be treated like a sacred vault — but as a strategic instrument. Used wisely, with rules, transparency, and long-term planning.

Right now, transfers from the Fund are often made for short-term budget needs and don’t follow macroeconomic cycles. The IMF warns that countries like Kazakhstan — with short production horizons — tend to change budget rules opportunistically, undermining future generations.

So, the real problem is not the Fund itself, but how we use it: unsystematic, uncoordinated spending with no lasting impact.

In short: the National Fund should become a tool for sustainable development and intergenerational fairness. But to achieve that, we need clear rules, strategic goals, and public accountability.

 
 

Khanet Ayakyoz, macro analyst, researcher, PhD candidate, specifically for www.economyKZ.org

Scroll to Top