EC[ON]OMY

Kazakhstan’s grey imports: a hidden economic challenge

Foreign trade is one of the most sensitive areas of macroeconomic statistics. How accurately imports and exports are measured directly affects the assessment of the current account, exchange rate stability, and the true scale of capital outflows. For many years, Kazakhstan had a segment that formally remained outside official statistics but had a real and noticeable impact on the economy. This segment was the so-called grey import of cars.

This issue is examined in the economic study “Assessment of Grey Car Imports in Kazakhstan’s Balance of Payments”, prepared by specialists of the Balance of Payments Department of the National Bank of Kazakhstan – Nurlan Ospanov, Zhansaya Daurenova, Oksana Yelizarova, Azat Uskenbayev, and Zhasulan Muratov (Economic Research No. 2022-9, December 2022).

The main conclusion is clear and unambiguous: the scale of unrecorded car imports was systemic, long-lasting, and economically significant. Ignoring it distorted key balance-of-payments indicators for many years.

Where grey imports came from

Over the past decade, the number of cars with foreign license plates – mainly from Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) countries – increased sharply on Kazakhstan’s roads. Formally, these vehicles could be classified as temporarily imported. In reality, many of them were used permanently in Kazakhstan and operated by residents for years.

The core problem was that car imports by individuals from EAEU countries were not reflected in official customs statistics. The absence of customs borders within the union, combined with the widespread use of power-of-attorney arrangements without a formal transfer of ownership, created a stable channel of unrecorded imports.

From a balance-of-payments perspective, these transactions are full imports: Kazakhstan residents pay foreign sellers in foreign currency, but the transaction never appears in trade statistics.

Why the scheme became widespread

The study shows that grey imports were driven by several strong economic incentives.

The first wave occurred in 2014–2015. A sharp depreciation of the Russian ruble made cars from Russia significantly cheaper. The absence of a recycling fee and low registration costs made it easy to put such vehicles on the road in Kazakhstan. According to the National Bank, around 70,000 cars were imported but not recorded during this period, while the balance of payments missed nearly USD 942 million.

The second wave began after 2016 and was far larger and more persistent. It was triggered by the introduction of a recycling fee and a sharp increase in initial registration charges. By 2018, total registration costs could exceed the price of the car itself, especially for old and inexpensive vehicles.

Under these conditions, driving a car with foreign plates became an economically rational choice.

Why the state failed to see the problem

The authors describe serious institutional limits to enforcement and control. To operate a car in Kazakhstan, it was enough to have:

  • ⁠ ⁠an insurance policy,
  • ⁠ ⁠a valid technical inspection certificate,
  • ⁠ ⁠a power of attorney from a foreign owner.

All three documents could be renewed without actually taking the car out of the country. Surveys of owners of cars with Russian plates showed that many vehicles were used in Kazakhstan for one to three years without leaving the country, while insurance and technical inspections were renewed remotely.

Penalties for missing inspections were low, and there was virtually no effective control over the actual date of import.

How the National Bank estimated the scale of unrecorded imports

The key methodological innovation of the study was the use of the Unified Insurance Database. Any car operating on Kazakhstan’s roads must have insurance, which allowed researchers to identify vehicles with foreign plates through VIN codes.

Between 2015 and July 2022, the database recorded 1.6 million unique passenger cars with foreign plates. However, not all of them represented imports. The authors applied a conservative approach, guided by a simple rule: it is better to underestimate than to overestimate.

As a result, a sample of 533,000 vehicles was identified as highly likely to represent grey imports.

The profile of a grey-imported car

The analysis showed that most imported cars were old:

  • ⁠ ⁠28% were older than 15 years,
  • ⁠ ⁠about one-third were between 11 and 15 years old,
  • ⁠ ⁠cars younger than two years accounted for less than 8%.

By brand, the structure was dominated by:

  • ⁠ ⁠Lada – 38.4%,
  • ⁠ ⁠Toyota – 14.1%,
  • ⁠ ⁠followed by Daewoo, Nissan, GAZ, Honda, Hyundai, and Kia with smaller shares.

This confirms that grey imports were not aimed at the premium segment, but at cheap and worn-out vehicles, with clear social and environmental implications.

How much it cost the economy

To estimate the value of imports, the National Bank analyzed 120,200 car sale listings from open online platforms. Prices were calculated by brand and age, separately for cleared and non-cleared cars, with dealer margins taken into account.

A conservative estimate shows that from 2015 to July 2022, the value of grey car imports amounted to around USD 4.3 billion. Under less cautious assumptions, the figure could have reached USD 7.2 billion, but the authors deliberately avoided using maximum estimates.

The peak occurred in 2021, when grey imports exceeded USD 980 million in a single year.

How this changed the balance of payments

The study produced not only analytical insights but also practical results. Kazakhstan’s balance-of-payments statistics were revised starting from 2015 to include a conservative estimate of grey car imports.

This made it possible to:

  • ⁠ ⁠expand coverage of households’ external transactions,
  • ⁠ ⁠correct goods import figures,
  • ⁠ ⁠improve the overall balancing of the current account.

In effect, the National Bank officially acknowledged that a significant share of foreign currency outflows had previously remained invisible to macroeconomic statistics.

Why the findings go beyond the car market

This study is not only about cars. It shows how administrative distortions and price imbalances create shadow channels in external economic activity. High fees and regulatory barriers do not eliminate demand – they simply change the way it is satisfied. As a result, the state loses statistical control, and the economy loses transparency.

The National Bank’s research demonstrates that grey car imports were not a marginal phenomenon, but a persistent structural factor that distorted Kazakhstan’s balance of payments for many years. Accurate accounting of such operations is essential for a realistic assessment of the country’s external position and the effectiveness of economic policy. Without it, macroeconomic decisions are made on the basis of an incomplete picture.

Lina Yegil kizi, expert of the  portal EconomyKZ.org

Scroll to Top