Education is an investment in the future. But how wisely is this investment managed by the government? In 2024, Kazakhstan’s Ministry of Education was allocated more than 1 trillion tenge. The funds were aimed at supporting secondary education, financing public-private partnerships, and implementing 15 budget programs with 55 direct and 16 strategic goals. Officially, the ministry spent 100% of its annual budget. But do the numbers tell the whole story? What went according to plan – and what didn’t?
In this article we take a closer look at how the money was allocated, what the ministry prioritized, where the gaps were, and what all this means for the future of education in Kazakhstan.
The ministry’s work in 2024 followed its Development Plan for 2023–2027, first approved on March 2, 2023 (Order No. 59), and later updated on:
• January 30, 2024 (No. 15),
• July 22, 2024 (No. 185),
• February 28, 2025 (No. 34).
The ministry’s budget programs were approved by Order No. 379 on December 15, 2023, and revised on July 17 and December 31, 2024. These updates reflected shifting national education priorities and allowed the government to adjust its financial planning during the year.
At the beginning of 2024, the Ministry of Education was allocated 1,019,465,418,000 tenge. However, the plan changed over time:
• Revised budget: 1,043,664,235,000 tenge
• Final figure after adding five new programs:1,067,468,554,200 tenge
The main reason for the budget increase was a rise in spending on public education contracts with private schools – part of a broader strategy to expand public-private partnerships in the education sector.
In terms of financial reporting:
• Executed amount: 1,067,187,027,200 tenge – 100% of the final annual plan.
• Unexecuted amount: 281,527,000 tenge
• Unspent but allocated funds: 6,743,200 tenge (well within acceptable limits)
On the surface, the execution looks flawless. But numbers alone don’t measure effectiveness. The key question is – what was actually achieved with the money?
The Ministry implemented 15 budget programs, each with specific targets:
• 55 direct (operational) results: 49 achieved, 6 not achieved
• 16 strategic outcomes: 15 achieved, 1 not achieved
In other words, around 11% of planned results were not met, despite the full budget being spent. This raises important questions about the quality of planning, monitoring, and execution.