Maintaining affordable energy prices is a key reason many governments regulate fuel and electricity costs. This intervention aims to keep prices low for consumers.
The global energy crisis has intensified measures to ensure energy affordability. In 2023 according to the International Energy Agency (IEA), these efforts cost approximately $900 billion. This amount includes direct grants, vouchers, tax incentives, and price controls.
Governments, particularly in developing and emerging market economies, continued to heavily subsidize fossil fuel use in 2023. Total subsidies had reached $620 billion. In comparison, only $70 billion was allocated to support clean energy for consumers.
In 2022 for the first time global fossil fuel consumption subsidies exceeded $1 trillion. This surge resulted from imbalances in energy markets driven by the global energy crisis and the conflict in Ukraine.
Kazakhstan ranks among the top 15 countries for nominal fuel subsidies globally. In terms of per capita subsidies and subsidies as a percentage of GDP, it ranks in the top 10.
Fuel subsidies in Kazakhstan are mainly provided through:
• Direct subsidies to energy producers;
• Financing energy infrastructure projects;
• Tax breaks for extraction companies;
• Price controls on goods and services that dominate coal production costs.
Global experience shows that fossil fuel subsidies can hinder low-carbon development goals. These subsidies often lead to higher energy consumption, slower renewable energy adoption, and artificially low tariffs.
Another critical issue is the effectiveness of such subsidy mechanisms, especially with limited application of market-based tariff-setting methods.
According to IEA data, from 2010 to 2023, Kazakhstan’s annual direct and indirect fuel subsidies averaged 5.8% of GDP. In 2023 subsidy spending exceeded $15 billion. Over 70% of this was concentrated in the oil and electricity sectors.

Figure 1 – Dynamics of Fuel Subsidies in Kazakhstan, $ billion

Figure 2 – Structure of Fuel Subsidies in Kazakhstan, %
To manage and redistribute fuel subsidies effectively, several factors must be considered, especially within the framework of the “Tariff for Investment” program. This program proposes raising energy tariffs to encourage investments in infrastructure modernization and efficiency improvements. However, higher tariffs could lead to negative social impacts if compensatory measures are not implemented.
Firstly, subsidy redistribution should prioritize vulnerable population groups. For instance, part of the funds could expand energy-related social assistance for low-income families to reduce their utility expenses.
Secondly, subsidies should support renewable energy development and energy efficiency projects. This approach will lower long-term costs associated with fossil fuel dependency and accelerate the transition to a low-carbon economy.
Given Kazakhstan’s high fossil fuel subsidy levels, redirecting these funds toward renewable energy and grid modernization is a strategic necessity.
Transparency in tariff setting and oversight of natural monopolies’ commitments are also crucial. Introducing incentive-based tariff methods and automated risk management systems, as outlined in the program, can improve infrastructure management and build public trust.
Lastly, public education campaigns on energy-saving practices are essential. These efforts can reduce household expenses and overall energy consumption, which is particularly critical during a global energy crisis.