EC[ON]OMY

How Taxes Shape Innovation

Innovation drives long-term economic growth. While we often picture lone inventors working out of passion, in reality, innovation is an economic activity. It requires money, infrastructure, and-crucially-motivation. Taxes are one of the most powerful tools governments can use to influence that motivation.

In their landmark paper (NBER, 2020) Ufuk Akcigit and Stefanie Stantcheva show how tax policies affect not only how much innovation happens, but where, how, and by whom. This article distills the key insights from their research and explores what they mean for a country like Kazakhstan.

Tax policy shapes innovation in five key ways:

1. It influences the amount and quality of new inventions;

2. It affects where inventors and companies choose to work;

3. It impacts business growth and dynamism;

4. It changes the quality and structure of firms and teams;

5. It steers the direction of research-from clean tech to basic science.

Innovation is an investment in the future. Taxes shift the balance of expected costs and rewards, and that changes the choices people make.

The researchers examined nearly a century of data on U.S. inventors, patents, and state tax rates. The findings are clear:

•  A 10% increase in personal income taxes reduces patent quantity by 6–7%, and quality by 8–9%;

•  These effects start showing after one year and last for about three years.

Inventors working in companies are especially sensitive to tax changes. Bottom line: poorly designed tax policy can slow innovation, while smart design can unlock it.

Taxes influence where innovation happens:

•  In the U.S., inventors move from high-tax states to low-tax ones;

•  Foreign inventors are far more sensitive to tax rates than domestic ones (elasticity = 1.0).

However, innovation hubs-places with lots of R&D activity-can reduce tax sensitivity. Why? Because people want to be where the action is. That’s the power of agglomeration.

Over the past 30 years the U.S. has seen declining business dynamism: fewer startups, greater market concentration, and slower innovation diffusion.

Tax policy can reverse this trend by:

•  Offering tax breaks for startups;

•  Supporting venture capital (VC)-backed firms with favorable tax rates;

•  Providing smaller firms with tax advantages to encourage radical innovation.

On the flip side, taxes can reinforce monopolies if politically connected firms receive favorable treatment. That stifles competition and innovation.

Not all firms are equally productive. Taxes can help allocate resources better:

•  Inefficient firms may exit, freeing up talent and capital for better players;

•  R&D incentives should reward outcomes, not just spending.

Akcigit and Stantcheva propose:

•  Lower tax rates for high-profit firms;

•  Diminishing marginal R&D subsidies to avoid subsidizing inefficient firms.

Tax incentives alone aren’t enough if you lack skilled people. Education is essential:

•  Poor but talented students need access to higher education;

•  In countries with limited education access, R&D subsidies alone don’t deliver.

Kazakhstan, for example, has many talented youth. But scholarships alone won’t build an innovation economy. You need the right mix of incentives and access.

Governments can use taxes to guide research:

1. Basic vs Applied Research:

◦ Basic science gets underfunded because returns take time;

◦ Tax policy should offer higher subsidies for basic research (up to 5x).

2. Clean vs Dirty Technology:

◦ Carbon taxes alone don’t work if green tech isn’t yet competitive;

◦ Start with R&D subsidies for green tech, then gradually raise pollution taxes.

Kazakhstan’s reliance on extractive industries makes this particularly relevant.

What Kazakhstan Can Do

  • R&D Tax Reform: Introduce performance-based, progressive incentives; 
  • Support Venture Capital: Target tax breaks to VC-backed projects, not all startups; 
  • Favor Small Firms: They take more risks and drive breakthrough innovation; 
  • Link Education and Innovation: Offer scholarships, build regional innovation hubs; 
  • Guide Research Focus: Provide higher subsidies for basic and green technologies.

Taxes aren’t just about revenue-they shape the future. Used wisely, tax policy can drive innovation, boost competitiveness, and reshape economies. U.S. data shows how responsive inventors and firms are to tax incentives. Kazakhstan can take these insights and build a smarter, innovation-friendly tax system that supports long-term growth.

 

Scroll to Top