EC[ON]OMY

Groundwater Governance: Lessons for Kazakhstan

When we think of farming, we usually picture land, labor, and equipment. But in the 21st century the most critical resource for U.S. farmers is water. Not just a natural element, but a vital form of capital-without it, there’s no planting, no harvest.

As climate change accelerates droughts and disrupts rainfall patterns, access to groundwater becomes a defining factor in agricultural sustainability. Yet, unlike land, water rights in the U.S. are often unclear. Open access to groundwater has led to depletion, higher costs, and disputes. Without clear rules, farmers face declining land values, uncertainty, and the burden of expensive adaptation.

That’s why the U.S. is now shifting toward institutional reform in groundwater governance. Though complex, this shift offers critical lessons-not only for American agriculture but also for countries like Kazakhstan, where water scarcity, irrigation pressures, and lack of regulation pose growing challenges.

Before the mid-20th century, U.S. farms depended mainly on surface water from rivers, lakes, and reservoirs. But after the 1940s, groundwater use expanded rapidly. Electricity, more powerful pumps, and advanced drilling tech made it easier and cheaper.

Farmers, especially in the dry western U.S., began relying on artesian wells. Groundwater became a safety net during drought years.

But there was a catch. Groundwater was treated as a shared resource-there were no defined ownership rights. Anyone could pump as much as they wanted. This open-access system led to:

•  Aquifer depletion

•  Rising pumping costs

•  Falling groundwater levels

•  Land subsidence

•  Declining water quality and crop yields

Today groundwater provides up to 80% of water used in U.S. agriculture, particularly in states like California, Arizona, and Nebraska. But this lifeline is institutionally fragile.

Without clear water rights, farmers enter a race to extract. The result:

•  More investment in pumping equipment

•  Deeper wells as water tables fall

•  Conflicts between neighbors over aquifers

•  A drop in land value

In short, water is no longer an asset-it becomes a source of loss and conflict.

In 2014 California passed the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA). It introduced:

•  Local Groundwater Sustainability Agencies (GSAs)

•  Pumping limits

•  Plans to balance groundwater use and recharge over time

While this was a major step toward sustainability, the transition came at a cost.

Estimates show that reducing groundwater use by just one acre-foot (about 325,000 gallons) can lower land values by up to 55%in regulated areas.

Why do farmers resist?

•  Losses are immediate; benefits are long-term

•  Compensation mechanisms are unclear

•  Small farms are especially vulnerable

Kazakhstan faces similar issues:

•  Drying rivers and climate-driven droughts

•  Overuse of groundwater in the south and west

•  Lack of strong institutions for managing aquifers

While in the U.S. these issues affect land prices, in Kazakhstan they threaten the very survival of irrigated agriculture. Regions like Taldykorgan, Shardara, and Aktobe are seeing unchecked drilling and fragmented water use-with serious risks to both the environment and food security.

What can Kazakhstan learn?

1. Treat water as an economic asset-like land, it needs rules and oversight

2. Create water districts-transparent quotas, data monitoring, and farmer involvement

3. Design long-term compensation tools-subsidies, tax breaks, or insurance to support the transition

Water isn’t just about irrigation anymore. It’s a pillar of food systems, economic resilience, and national security. Without effective governance, it becomes a liability rather than an asset.

The U.S. experience proves one thing: Institutional reform is essential. Acting late is costly. Acting early is difficult-but it pays off.

For Kazakhstan, this means shedding the illusion of water abundance. Groundwater is finite. And like any form of capital, it must be protected, regulated, and managed for the future.

Prepared by: Lina Yegil kizi, expert of the  portal EconomyKZ.org

Scroll to Top