EC[ON]OMY

Enhancing Kazakhstan’s governance through expert collaboration

Every year, Kazakhstan’s President delivers the well-known annual Address to the Nation. Afterward, a precise mechanism is launched to implement the key directives. A detailed action plan is approved and distributed among government agencies. From there, the plan moves down the administrative chain – from minister to vice minister, to department director, to deputy director, then to division heads, and finally to leading and senior specialists. These are the people who actually bring the President’s initiatives to life.

At this level, the burden of preparing and executing effective – sometimes innovative – solutions falls on the shoulders of these specialists. Yet, due to frequent staff turnover in public institutions, they often lack sufficient experience to produce such solutions.

The reverse process – from bottom to top – also has its challenges. Even when lower-level employees come up with valuable initiatives or successful case studies, they must carefully navigate the hierarchy to ensure their ideas are approved at every step. The risk of rejection or negative evaluation discourages many from proposing bold or unconventional ideas.

As a result, those who start the implementation process may lack experience, while strong ideas that do emerge often fail to reach practical application due to poor vertical coordination within the system.

To address this issue, it is proposed to create a Union of Government Initiatives – a platform where experienced civil servants can share their professional insights and policy suggestions directly with the country’s top leadership. This would be supported by a dedicated digital platform.

This platform, operating under the Union of Government Initiatives, would serve as a coordination hub for collecting, refining, and promoting expert ideas.

Who Can Join

Membership would be open to individuals with at least 10 years of experience in the public sector (excluding political appointments), including at least 2 years in a specialist role(senior, leading, or chief specialist) and at least 3 years of experience in regional administration (in a local government or regional office of a central body). This ensures that both theoretical experience (from central institutions) and practical expertise (from regional levels) are represented.

Participants meeting the experience criteria would be automatically included in the platform, without the need for approval from superiors. This helps avoid cases where officials might be pressured to refuse participation. In this way, the system captures the expertise of professionals who are capable of making balanced and practical judgments.

Initially, the platform’s digests (short analytical summaries) would be available only to the Presidential Administration or directly to the President. The review process would have two levels:

1.⁠ ⁠Accepted for consideration – the material is forwarded (and potentially included in the next Presidential Address) for further review and implementation by relevant central or local government bodies;

2.⁠ ⁠Rejected from consideration – materials deemed unsuitable are filtered out early, saving government time and resources.

Participants may choose to submit their analyses or proposals anonymously, without disclosing authorship. However, the system would allow moderators to contact authors for clarification if necessary.

Each submission should not only describe a problem but also include practical recommendations, international best practices, and a clear implementation mechanism.

Thus, the platform is not a complaint channel, but a source of constructive ideas. To ensure this, clear requirements should be established for all submissions, including:

  • ⁠ ⁠Analysis of the current situation (facts and data);
  • ⁠ ⁠International comparisons or best practices;
  • ⁠ ⁠Concrete proposal with implementation details;
  • ⁠ ⁠Resource assessment (what is needed for implementation);
  • ⁠ ⁠Expected outcome (measurable results);
  • ⁠ ⁠Exclusion of personal grievances or unrelated issues.

To encourage participation, a monthly ranking of the best ideas can be introduced – either anonymously (by ID number) or with the author’s name (if they agree).

Monthly thematic digests covering key areas of public policy would provide government leaders with an alternative source of professional expertise, complementing official reports.

Importantly, this proposed model does not replace the existing hierarchy of public administration. It serves as an additional expert resource. Each management level remains responsible for policy implementation in its respective area. However, senior officials will gain a new way to cross-check official reports with feedback from practitioners, while experienced specialists will have a direct channel to influence national policy formation.

Over time, such a system could become a powerful instrumentfor generating effective solutions by using the vast expert potential already present within the public sector, beyond social media commentary or external independent experts.

Scroll to Top