EC[ON]OMY

Economic impacts of tenge appreciation: a detailed analysis

The real exchange rate of the tenge does not always strengthen for healthy reasons. This is the key conclusion of the study “The Contribution of the Balassa-Samuelson Effect to the Dynamics of the Real Exchange Rate of the Tenge” by the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The paper was prepared by Berdibek Turabay, Meruert Almagambetova, and Azat Uskenbayev (Balance of Payments Department, February 2024).

The study is part of a broader analytical series by the National Bank on the external sector of the economy. It focuses on a question that is rarely discussed outside expert circles: why the tenge is strengthening in real terms, and what exactly stands behind it – real efficiency gains or the accumulation of structural imbalances.

The authors start with the right framing. The real exchange rate is not just a result of inflation and the nominal exchange rate. It is an indicator of economic competitiveness and a reflection of the economy’s structure. A stronger real exchange rate can be the result of technological progress. But it can also be driven by commodity dependence, fiscal pressure, and rising prices in the non-tradable sector.

The study draws a clear line between these two cases.

At the core of the paper is a test of the Balassa-Samuelson hypothesis for Kazakhstan. According to classical theory, if labor productivity in the tradable sector grows faster than in trading partners, wages rise, services and domestic goods become more expensive, inflation accelerates, and the real exchange rate strengthens. In a “healthy” economy, this reflects higher complexity and better quality of production.

The key question is whether this mechanism works in Kazakhstan, and if it does, how exactly.

To answer this, the authors use vector autoregression (VAR) models covering the period from 2001 to 2023. The analysis focuses on three currency pairs: the tenge against the euro, the ruble, and the yuan. The main explanatory variable is the productivity differential, measured as GDP per employed person.

The results are asymmetric.

In relations with the Eurozone, the Balassa-Samuelson effect is statistically confirmed. Higher labor productivity growth in Kazakhstan relative to the Eurozone is indeed associated with an appreciation of the real exchange rate of the tenge. Formally, this looks exactly like the textbook case. But here the study makes an important clarification: the nature of this effect in Kazakhstan is not classical.

Productivity growth is driven mainly by the commodity sector. High export revenues flow into the National Fund and are then redistributed into the economy through fiscal channels. These funds fuel the non-tradable sector and government spending, pushing inflation higher without a proportional improvement in the production structure. This creates a form of “paper growth,” where prices rise faster than output and real efficiency.

The exchange rate channel also plays a role. Commodity exports generate a steady inflow of foreign currency, while the nominal exchange rate of the tenge either strengthens or does not weaken enough to offset the inflation gap. As a result, the real exchange rate appreciates. But this appreciation does not improve competitiveness. On the contrary, it weakens the position of non-commodity sectors.

The authors state this clearly: such appreciation does not affect commodity exports, since their revenues and costs are denominated in foreign currency. However, it hurts exports of manufactured goods and production with high value added that targets the domestic market. This is a classic case of “Dutch disease.”

The picture is very different with Russia. For the tenge-ruble pair, the Balassa-Samuelson effect is not confirmed. Moreover, faster productivity growth in Kazakhstan is associated with a real depreciation of the tenge against the ruble. This result contradicts standard theory.

The study explains this through a combination of factors. Both countries are developing economies, and the productivity gap between them is much smaller than the gap with the Eurozone. Exchange rate regimes also played a major role. Kazakhstan maintained a fixed exchange rate for a long time, while Russia used a managed float. This distorted market signals and allowed external imbalances to build up. As a result, the nominal exchange rate did not reflect real trade conditions for years, and Kazakhstan’s trade deficit with Russia persisted despite exchange rate movements.

The situation with China is also unfavorable for Kazakhstan in terms of the Balassa-Samuelson effect. Labor productivity in China grows faster than in Kazakhstan, which leads to an appreciation of the real exchange rate of the yuan, not the tenge. This is consistent with the structure of trade. Chinese exports to Kazakhstan are highly diversified, while Kazakhstan’s exports to China remain narrow and commodity-based. Export growth is accompanied by rising imports, without creating a stable positive trade balance.

The final conclusion of the study is very clear. The real exchange rate of the tenge is strengthening, but this appreciation is technical and driven by fiscal and commodity factors. It does not reflect qualitative economic upgrading, is not linked to technological progress or real efficiency gains, and does not improve the competitiveness of non-commodity sectors.

The authors stress that the real exchange rate is a mirror of the economic structure. It is not an independent tool for boosting competitiveness. Without sterilization of oil revenues, without counter-cyclical fiscal policy, and without real development of high value-added sectors, appreciation of the real exchange rate will continue to work against long-term growth.

This is the main message of the study: the problem is not that the tenge is strengthening, but why it is strengthening and what exactly is driving that process.

Lina Yegil kizi, expert of the EconomyKZ.org portal

Scroll to Top