Cities have been considered as the engines of economic growth for a long time now. They bring people together, facilitate business, and encourage innovation. But just how significant is this impact? Do large cities truly provide substantial economic benefits, or is their role overestimated? To answer these questions, we turn to the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) study, “Are Big Cities Important for Economic Growth?” (Matthew Turner and David N. Weil, 2025), which explores the macroeconomic impact of cities.
In this article we will discuss the following:
• How does the agglomeration effect influence labor productivity?
• Why do big cities become hubs for innovation?
• What happens if urban growth is restricted?
• What lessons can be learned for Kazakhstan and other developing countries?
What is the Agglomeration Effect?
The agglomeration effect refers to the economic advantages that come from concentrating people, businesses, and infrastructure in one place. It manifests in three key areas:
1. Production efficiency. Businesses lower logistics costs and gain access to skilled labor.
2. Knowledge exchange. Scientists, engineers, and entrepreneurs share ideas more rapidly.
3. Innovation growth. High population density leads to an increase in patents and technological breakthroughs.
The NBER study shows that a 10% increase in a city’s population boosts labor productivity by 0.8-1.3%. This highlights the benefits of having many people working and interacting in close proximity.
How Do Large Cities Improve Productivity?
The agglomeration effect boosts productivity in two key ways:
1. Economies of scale. Large cities reduce business costs through shared infrastructure, advanced logistics, and high competition.
2. Higher labor productivity. According to the NBER study, wages and GDP per capita are higher in metropolitan areas than in smaller towns due to more career growth opportunities and better access to education.
For example, New York, San Francisco, and London generate significantly higher GDP per capita than smaller cities. In 2010 the 27 largest U.S. cities accounted for 54% of national GDP, despite having only 47% of the population.
Cities and Innovation: The Role of Patents
Large cities not only boost productivity but also serve as centers for innovation. The NBER study found that in 2010, 65% of all patents in the U.S. were registered in the ten largest metropolitan areas. This is due to:
• High concentrations of scientific and technical professionals;
• Easy access to investment and venture capital;
• Proximity to universities and research centers.
However, different cities specialize in different areas. For instance, San Francisco leads in IT-related patents, while Detroit dominates the automotive sector.
What Happens When Urban Growth is Limited?
Researchers modeled scenarios where cities were restricted to populations of either 1 million or 100,000 people. The results were surprising:
• If cities were limited to 1 million people, U.S. GDP in 2010 would have dropped by only 8%.
• If cities were capped at 100,000 people, GDP would have declined by 16-20%.
This suggests that while the agglomeration effect is important, it is not the sole driver of economic growth. Alternative strategies, such as digital transformation and remote work, can help maintain economic efficiency even in less densely populated areas.
Lessons for Kazakhstan and Other Developing Countries
Urbanization plays a crucial role in Kazakhstan’s economic development. However, not all cities are equally productive. Almaty and Astana have the highest agglomeration benefits, but other regions like Shymkent or Karaganda could explore alternative strategies:
• Developing industrial clusters to attract investment;
• Establishing technology parks and startup incubators;
• Investing in digital infrastructure to support remote work.
The experience of developed nations shows that success is not just about expanding megacities but about managing human capital and infrastructure wisely.
While cities are an essential part of economic growth, their impact is not unlimited. The agglomeration effect enhances productivity and innovation, but as the NBER study shows, restricting urban growth does not necessarily lead to economic collapse.
For Kazakhstan the key is not just to expand major cities but to develop all regions by investing in technology, education, and business support. Urbanization should be a tool for growth, not an end goal.
Prepared by: Alen Serik specifically for www.economyKZ.org


