EC[ON]OMY

Building personal responsibility in Kazakhstan’s social sector

Singapore’s economic success is rooted in the philosophy of Lee Kuan Yew, who openly rejected the Western model of social welfare. Watching how generous benefits in Europe turned citizens into passive consumers, the founding father of Singapore chose a different path – personal responsibility.

Instead of shifting responsibility for people’s lives onto taxpayers, Singapore created a unique system called the Central Provident Fund (CPF). It turned every working person into the owner of their own capital through three personal accounts:

  • ⁠ ⁠Ordinary Account – housing, mortgages, education
  • ⁠ ⁠Special Account – retirement savings
  • ⁠ ⁠Medisave Account – healthcare and medical insurance

This approach transformed Singapore from a country of fishermen into a nation where more than 80 percent of citizens own their homes, while government spending remains relatively low.

Kazakhstan spends huge amounts on the social sector. Almost 60 percent of the state budget goes there. Yet the system continues to fail. Social protection costs reach 5 percent of GDP, roughly 15 billion dollars. At the same time, transparency remains a serious issue.

Healthcare financing is especially problematic. According to the national budget:

  • ⁠ ⁠2026 – 5.25 billion dollars
  • ⁠ ⁠2027 – 5.26 billion dollars

Over two years, more than 9.1 billion dollars will be transferred as targeted contributions to the Social Health Insurance Fund.

The current Kazakh model allows citizens’ contributions to dissolve into faceless budget flows. This creates ideal conditions for corruption, false reporting, and fictitious medical services.

Recent proposals to move the Social Health Insurance Fund from the Ministry of Health to the Ministry of Finance look like an attempt to treat the symptoms, not the disease. It is nothing more than a weak hope that new administrators will be more honest. There is a Kazakh saying: “Even an angel loses the right path when it sees gold.” As long as trillions remain “nobody’s money,” changing institutions will not remove temptation.

A real solution exists. It is the creation of a Unified Social Capital system, combining the pension fund, the health insurance fund, and the housing savings bank into a single structure with personalized accounts, modeled after Singapore.

What this gives to citizens

Control.

When healthcare contributions are stored in a personal account similar to Medisave, people become the best auditors. A clinic cannot invent a visit if real money is taken directly from the citizen’s account.

Inheritance.

Unused medical funds should not disappear into a fund. They should move into pension savings or be passed on to heirs.

Leaving the shadow economy.

People gain a clear reason to work officially. Every tenge of a “white” salary becomes their future home, quality healthcare, and secure old age – not a source of enrichment for corrupt actors.

Bringing three funds into a single system would:

  • ⁠ ⁠reduce corruption through transparency
  • ⁠ ⁠lower administrative costs

In developed countries, administration takes around 4 percent. In Kazakhstan, bureaucracy consumes far more. In my view, moving toward a model of personal responsibility is the only way to turn Kazakhstan’s social system from a “bottomless pit” for budget trillions into a real foundation of national prosperity.

Yerlan Karimov, independent expert, specifically for www.economyKZ.org

Scroll to Top