EC[ON]OMY

Balancing AI and human values in education

In his August Address, President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev outlined a strategic priority: building a nation of thinkers, capable of acting in a world of rapid technological change. He stressed the importance of developing critical thinking, nurturing responsibility and patriotism, and encouraging creativity among young people. At the same time, he emphasized that technology is a tool – not a substitute for human personality.

According to the President, schools should not only transfer knowledge but also raise citizens who can analyze information, see problems from different angles, and apply technology for the benefit of society. This raises a central dilemma for modern education: how do we integrate AI into learning while preserving essential human qualities like empathy, creativity, and social responsibility?

Digital Childhood: The Price of Progress

Global statistics highlight the urgency of this challenge. Between 2010 and 2019, rates of depression among teenagers grew by more than 50%, suicides rose by 48%, and among girls aged 10–14 the increase reached 131%. At the same time, international PISA studies show declining results in math, science, and humanities.

American psychologist Jonathan Haidt links these trends to smartphones and social media. He notes that children now sleep less, feel more anxiety, and lose face-to-face communication skills. His advice is simple but radical: no smartphones before 14, no social media before 16, phone restrictions in schools, and a return to free play and offline experiences.

Similar concerns were voiced by British actress and public figure Sophie Winkleman at ARC 2025 in her speech “The Most Compelling Argument Against Tech in Schools.” She cited alarming figures:

  • ⁠ ⁠Suicides among girls rose by 167%, among boys by 91%;
  • ⁠ ⁠Hospitalizations for eating disorders increased sixfold;
  • ⁠ ⁠Cases of self-harm jumped by 500%;
  • ⁠ ⁠One in three children now has myopia, with forecasts of 1 billion cases by 2050.

She argued that screen culture is replacing real communication and creating “a generation of app users, not citizens able to make responsible decisions.” She also noted that only 7% of EdTech companies in the UK back their products with independent evidence of effectiveness. Her key message: “We must use technology as a servant, not a master.”

The lack of EdTech verification is a global issue. In the U.S., only a small share of products undergo independent testing. Kazakhstan has no nationwide evaluations yet, but there are success stories. For example, introducing MOOCs in several universities raised student performance by 10–19%. Another initiative, CodiTeach (supported by UNICEF), became part of the global ecosystem of Digital Public Goods (DPGs), designed to ensure accessibility and long-term results.

Still, academic performance alone is not enough – the real test is how digital environments affect teenagers’ mental health.

Fresh Data on Teen Mental Health (2023–2024)

  • ⁠ ⁠Global (WHO): Nearly 1 in 7 adolescents (14%) aged 10–19 experience mental disorders such as depression and anxiety; suicide is the third leading cause of death among 15–29-year-olds.
  • ⁠ ⁠USA (2021–2023):

o 40% of teens (12–17) felt persistent depression or hopelessness;

o 20% seriously considered suicide;

o 9–10% attempted it.

  • ⁠ ⁠Europe & OECD (2018–2022): Teen life satisfaction declined, fewer 15-year-olds could detect misinformation, and empathy levels fell.

These numbers show that “digital childhood” and education sustainability are not academic debates – they are urgent life issues.

Central Asia’s Reality

  • ⁠ ⁠According to the Mental Health and Wellbeing Index (based on the Mental State of the World model), Kazakhstan ranks 76th out of 82 countries with a score of 52.3. Uzbekistan is slightly higher at 74th with 54.5 points.
  • ⁠ ⁠The HBSC Report (2021/2022) shows worsening life satisfaction among Central Asian teens, especially older girls.
  • ⁠ ⁠In Kazakhstan, digital initiatives are emerging to address this. A project with Data for Children Collaborative and UNICEF analyzed the country’s Digital Mental Health Ecosystem, mapping platforms that can support teenagers through AI-based monitoring of online discussions.

The conclusion is clear: in Central Asia, mental health is as critical as academic outcomes. As digitalization and AI enter schools, the key question becomes not only what to teach, but how to balance technology and well-being.

AI and Sustainable Development: Striking a Balance

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman once said his child “will never be smarter than AI” – and that this is not a concern, but rather a positive sign. “My children will grow up far more capable than us by learning to use AI in ways we cannot even imagine,” he remarked.

Altman’s view is that the future is not about competing with AI, but growing alongside it. AI should expand human potential, not replace it. Still, he warns against blind trust: relying too heavily on systems like ChatGPT risks eroding critical thinking, since AI remains prone to mistakes. This calls for thoughtful regulation and teaching children how to think independently.

UNESCO echoes this in its report “Technology in Education: A Tool on Whose Terms?” The key message: technology should empower teachers, not replace them. Priorities must include digital literacy, the ability to distinguish fact from disinformation, and the ethical use of technology.

Global Practices: What Different Countries Teach

The world is searching for a balance between introducing AI into education and preserving the human side of learning. Countries take different approaches, but the shared goal is the same: to prepare a generation that doesn’t just use algorithms but thinks independently.

China has focused on large-scale AI adoption, introducing AI lessons even in primary school. But it draws a strict line: during the gaokao, the national university entrance exam, access to algorithms is fully blocked. This ensures students build future-oriented skills while keeping honesty and independent thinking intact.

Finland remains a pioneer of interdisciplinary learning. Its school programs are built around real-life cases: students solve tasks that combine math, natural sciences, and social studies. This approach develops systems thinking and the ability to see connections where traditional education separates subjects.

Singapore introduced design thinking from the early years of school. Children learn not just to come up with ideas, but to turn them into prototypes, test them, and refine them as a team. School here is seen less as a place for memorization and more as a laboratory for problem-solving.

France took a different path with its E3D program, which formalizes ecological and social education. Since 2023, students have received more practice in math and writing, but also a stronger emphasis on sustainable development as part of national identity.

Switzerland is known for experimenting with learning formats. Its Learning Circles project focuses not on tests and exams but on the joy of learning: students work in groups, receive creative feedback, and develop independent thinking.

The United Kingdom takes a pragmatic approach. AI helps automate teachers’ routine tasks – from lesson planning to performance analysis. But decision-making power stays with teachers: technology acts as an assistant, not a replacement.

The United States is piloting systemic experiments. In several states, education departments are testing AI platforms to identify students at risk of dropping out or to personalize learning. But debates over privacy and equal access remain central: innovation must not deepen inequality.

Kazakhstan: A School of the Future or a Factory for Industry?

Kazakhstan is betting big on AI. Astana Hub already unites more than 1,500 participants, and in 2025 the International Artificial Intelligence Center alem.ai will open in Astana – a 20,000 m² educational and research complex. Its goals are ambitious: $5 billion in AI solution exports by 2029, training 1,000 specialists every year, and launching 100 startups.

But these ambitions raise deeper questions. Will the new center become a place where students develop creativity, critical thinking, and social skills – or will it simply train “industry workers”? To what extent will the project embed the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and ESG principles? After all, digitalization is not just about the economy and exports. It’s also about health and well-being (SDG 3): how do we protect young people from the risks of “digital childhood,” addiction, and reduced socialization?

British actress and activist Sophie Winkleman warns that if digital initiatives ignore social consequences, they risk creating a generation of app users, not citizens capable of responsibility and empathy.

Other experts echo these concerns. American journalist, educator, and bestselling author Esther Wojcicki (known as the “godmother of Silicon Valley”) stresses that the future of education cannot be reduced to mastering technology. She created a journalism program at Palo Alto High School and raised three daughters who each achieved global success – from leading YouTube to founding 23andMe. Wojcicki also founded the Moonshots in Education Movement and serves on boards of leading U.S. education organizations, continuing to shape the debate on schools of the future.

Her TRICK method (Trust, Respect, Independence, Collaboration, Kindness) is built on the idea that only through trust, respect, and responsibility can we raise independent individuals who use technology for good, not harm.

Platon 5D: Kazakhstan’s Experience in a Global Context

This perspective frames Kazakhstan’s Platon 5D Thinkingmethod, presented at the 6th UNESCO International Conference on Learning Cities in Jubail (December 2024). It is based on five types of thinking – critical, creative, digital, systemic, and ethical – and is designed from the start with SDGs and ESG principles in mind.

Like Wojcicki’s TRICK, Platon 5D focuses on shaping personalities. Students learn to recognize social and environmental challenges, propose solutions, work in teams, and maintain a balance between technology and human values.

What makes Kazakhstan’s approach unique is that sustainability values are built into the program from the beginning. This makes it not just a digital education tool but also a way of fostering responsibility toward society and the environment. Early results are already visible:

  • ⁠ ⁠High school students at Nazarbayev Intellectual School in Karaganda designed a smart AI-powered recycling machine that identifies plastic types and feeds them back into the recycling cycle.
  • ⁠ ⁠At KarTU’s ESG, Creativity, and Innovation Center, students are building a biogas installation to see how organic waste turns into energy and to experiment with circular economy solutions.
  • ⁠ ⁠In Osakarovka, students and teachers created a digital bot for tracking schedules and homework, and developed an app to optimize freight logistics.
  • ⁠ ⁠An 11-year-old from Karaganda built a Telegram bot for eco-education, mixing games, eco-challenges, and carbon footprint calculations. As part of the EcoPlaton project, students planted 45 trees that provide about 162 kg of oxygen and absorb around 30 kg of CO₂ every year – a small but real contribution to reducing the city’s carbon footprint.
  • ⁠ ⁠A ninth-grader from Karaganda developed a computer game that teaches teenagers how to resist corruption.

These examples show that innovation is emerging not only in the capital but also in the regions. Platon 5D creates an environment where students turn ideas into real projects, linking creative and critical thinking with sustainable practices – from environmental awareness to green technologies and digital tools for local communities.

The world stands at the threshold of a new educational paradigm. Digitalization and AI bring vast opportunities, but without critical thinking, creativity, and ethics they can become threats. Kazakhstan’s initiatives – from national AI centers to author-driven approaches like Platon 5D – demonstrate that success is not defined by the number of technologies, but by the values they carry.

The school of the future should not just raise algorithm users but leaders who can guide technology for the good of society and the planet. The bigger question now is: can we integrate AI into education in a way that strengthens humanity rather than replacing it? Kazakhstan’s answer will help shape its role on the global education stage – and decide whether the country becomes an example for others seeking a balance between innovation and sustainability.

 Irina Kharitonova, Head of the Center for ESG, Creativity and Innovation, specifically for www.economyKZ.org

Scroll to Top