EC[ON]OMY

500 tenge or 0: what’s better for Astana’s economy?

The proposal to raise bus fares in Astana from 110 to 500 tenge has sparked strong public debate. Supporters say the increase is needed to improve the profitability of transport companies and reduce the burden of government subsidies. However, this idea raises serious questions – both social and economic.

First, a four- to fivefold price hike would hit low- and middle-income residents the hardest. It would reduce their purchasing power and add inflationary pressure to the economy.

Second, more expensive fares could push many people back into private cars, worsening traffic congestion, air pollution, and wear on city infrastructure.

In my view, supporting working citizens should be one of the key priorities of state policy. They are the backbone of the economy – creating value, paying taxes, and maintaining stable consumer demand.

That’s why introducing free public transportation in major cities such as Astana and Almaty could be one of the most effective measures – both socially and economically. It would help reduce traffic jams, improve air quality, and save people time and money.

Astana is one of the fastest-growing cities in Central Asia. But rapid development comes with rising car ownership and increasing pressure on infrastructure. Traffic congestion has already become a major economic problem.

1.⁠ ⁠Loss of time and productivity.

The city has about 685,000 employed residents, with an average monthly salary of 604,000 tenge. Assuming one hour of work is worth about 3,800 tenge, traffic delays cost the city roughly 2.6 billion tenge per day in lost productivity – time that could otherwise be spent working, studying, or running a business.

2.⁠ ⁠Higher fuel expenses.

Fuel consumption increases by 15–30% in heavy traffic. If each of Astana’s 385,000 cars wastes around 150 tenge per day in extra fuel, that’s 60 million tenge in daily losses across the city.

3.⁠ ⁠Slower economic growth.

Delays in logistics increase the cost of goods, disrupt deliveries, and hurt business competitiveness – ultimately making the city less attractive for investment.

Tallinn, the capital of Estonia, was one of the first European cities to introduce free public transport for its residents. The results were impressive: more passengers, fewer cars on the road, and better air quality. Even more interestingly, the city’s finances didn’t suffer. In fact, they improved – because many people registered as official residents to gain access to the free service, bringing in more local tax revenue.

In 2024, Kazakhstan spent 242 billion tenge on subsidies for transport companies – up 26 billion from the previous year. So, the question of how to finance free public transport is crucial.

I believe the necessary funds could be found through several practical measures:

1.⁠ ⁠“Luxury taxes” for status spending.

  • ⁠ ⁠Hold auctions for VIP license plates and raise fees for premium car numbers – this alone could bring in tens of billions of tenge.
  • ⁠ ⁠Allow paid window tinting on front windows, as practiced in Dushanbe and Tashkent. These measures don’t affect low-income citizens but generate steady revenue.

2.⁠ ⁠Smarter use of the recycling fee (utilization tax).

Currently, these funds are scattered across various projects. Redirecting them solely to bus purchases and public transport upgrades would make much more sense.

3.⁠ ⁠Lower administrative costs.

Free public transport eliminates the need for ticket inspectors and fare collection systems – reducing operational expenses significantly.

4.⁠ ⁠Reforming taxes on old vehicles.

Kazakhstan’s new draft Tax Code offers a 50% discount on older cars, which contradicts the nation’s decarbonization goals. Removing this benefit and introducing an eco-tax on aging vehicles could provide a sustainable funding source for public transport development.

For a city like Astana, the issue isn’t just about bus fares. It’s about economic efficiency, environmental responsibility, and quality of life. So, the real question – “500 tenge or 0?” – isn’t about numbers. It’s about the kind of future we want to build for our cities and citizens.

Yerlan Karimov, independent expert, specifically for www.economyKZ.org

Scroll to Top