EC[ON]OMY

11 key factors for successful sector reforms

The effectiveness of reforms largely depends on the correct way they are implemented. Many reforms face obstacles because key components are not resolved in advance. Very often, these gaps become visible only at the final stage of implementation.

Based on existing recommendations, this paper outlines 11 key cases as a set of priority measures that should be put in place before sectoral reforms begin. Together, they form a structural “framework” for reforms.

INSTITUTIONAL FOUNDATION

 1.⁠ ⁠Effective use of subordinate organizations

All reforms originate from the state, more precisely from government bodies. Therefore, before reforming any sector of the economy, it is logical to first put the public administration system itself in order.

Many people underestimate the role of subordinate organizations. In practice, these organizations often launch work processes and provide daily operational support to government bodies. Their work ranges from preparing urgent briefs, letters, and presentations to assisting in the drafting of laws and by-laws.

For this reason, reforms should start with these organizations. Improving their working conditions, including stable funding for 3–5 years, will directly improve the performance of government bodies themselves.

 2.⁠ ⁠Basic conditions for effective work of civil servants

The next step is to focus on the internal functioning of the public administration system. There are many internal issues, often linked to excessive workload and organizational bottlenecks.

If these problems persist, they lead to high staff turnover. This weakens institutional memory and reduces the overall quality of work. Addressing these issues is essential for sustainable reforms.

 3.⁠ ⁠Human resources policy in the civil service

The effectiveness of human resources policy in the civil service also requires close attention. It is important to consider the specific roles of central and local levels of government.

Central authorities often lack hands-on practical experience and knowledge of long-standing regional problems. At the local level, there is a strong need for analytical approaches and the application of international best practices. A balanced exchange between these levels is critical.

 4.⁠ ⁠The principle of pluralism at all levels

Another important measure is the introduction of the principle of pluralism at all levels of decision-making. This helps ensure that sound decisions pass through the system without distortion or unnecessary revisions.

The idea is to allow real discussion at every stage, from subordinate units to government meetings. These discussions should be properly documented when needed.

Once a decision is formally adopted by the responsible manager at each level, it must be implemented without hesitation.

Note: This does not apply to political decisions that have already been made.

 5.⁠ ⁠Consolidation of government initiatives

If the measures above are still not sufficient to ensure timely and high-quality decision-making, an alternative tool can be introduced. This involves consolidating government initiatives through a specialized digital platform.

Such a platform should rely on the expert capacity accumulated within the civil service, particularly experienced officials with at least 10 years of service, including experience at specialist and regional levels.

 6.⁠ ⁠Regulatory framework

The implementation of reforms usually starts with changes to laws and regulations. The quality of this work depends primarily on reasonable timelines for drafting and inter-agency coordination.

Currently, very short deadlines apply (for example, 5 working days for draft laws and 3 working days for government resolutions). These timelines increase the risk of poor-quality regulation.

Under time pressure, specialists must process many documents at once. This leads to overload and weak analysis. As a result, risks and errors may be missed, which later reduces the effectiveness of regulations.

For this reason, a more balanced approach is needed. A minimum of 10 working days should be set for the review and coordination of all regulatory acts.

RESOURCE SUSTAINABILITY

 7.⁠ ⁠Unified digital resource matrix

Even after the public administration system is prepared for reforms, there remains a constant need to ensure the rational use of national resources.

Today, there is no integrated control over how different projects-especially investment projects-affect the use and remaining balance of resources such as heating, electricity, water, and land.

There is no comprehensive assessment that shows how much each project consumes, what it delivers in return, and what reserve remains after all projects are implemented. To address this, a Unified Digital Resource Matrix is required.

 8.⁠ ⁠Planning for infrastructure development and renewal

The experience of the Soviet period, marked by mass construction followed by mass infrastructure deterioration, showed the importance of accounting for infrastructure life cycles. These cycles must be aligned with budget capacity.

Based on this experience, planning for the creation and renewal of infrastructure should be systematized and made long-term.

 9.⁠ ⁠Potential of existing manufacturing capacities

The state’s ability to address strategic tasks, including national defense and social obligations, depends largely on stable budget revenues.

This creates the need to produce goods and services domestically, with minimal reliance on imports and closer alignment with internal demand. That is why the development of manufacturing is so important.

However, before building new factories, a more effective first step is to fully use existing manufacturing capacities. Many plants operate at less than half of their potential.

By creating a dedicated digital platform, these idle capacities can be activated quickly, increasing output without the high costs of building new facilities.

10.⁠ ⁠Planning demand for sectoral resources

To ensure accurate forecasts of economic development, planning for sectoral resource needs should be based on the input–output model (Leontief inter-industry balance model). This approach allows for more precise and consistent calculations.

TECHNOLOGICAL SOVEREIGNTY

11.⁠ ⁠Science and artificial intelligence

The development of every sector depends on scientific progress and the protection of innovations. To ensure digital sovereignty, it is proposed to use the cultural code of the Kazakh language as a foundation.

This includes the creation of a National Patent Center and the integration of this approach into the national supercomputer and the AlemAI platform.

Training AI models using the cultural code of the Kazakh language will improve linguistic accuracy and allow researchers to work in a secure technological environment that fully reflects national interests.

Daulet Zhambaybekov, independent expert, specifically for www.economyKZ.org

Scroll to Top